ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / NEWS

'Pawn Stars' guest loses his cool after the expert brought down the price of his special guitar

When the show's guitar expert, Jesse Amoroso, cut the item's value by 75% from the asking price, the guest lost his cool.
PUBLISHED MAY 4, 2025
Screenshot showing Rick Harrison and the guest's reaction to the appraisal (Cover image source: YouTube/Pawn Stars)
Screenshot showing Rick Harrison and the guest's reaction to the appraisal (Cover image source: YouTube/Pawn Stars)

Rick Harrison of "Pawn Stars" is known to American viewers for his smooth negotiation skills to get rare items at prices lower than their valuation. But sometimes, guests walk in with cheap items that they believe to be expensive, and they don't go down without a fight. This happened when an elderly guest brought Semie Moseley's prototype "Gospel Guitar" to the world's most famous pawn shop, believing that it was worth over $100,000. Thus, when Harrison's friend and guitar expert, Jesse Amoroso, estimated that it wasn't worth more than $25,000, things got pretty heated up in the shop.

Screenshot showing the guest arguing with Jesse Amoroso on Pawn Stars (Image source: YouTube/Pawn Stars)
Screenshot showing the guest arguing with Jesse Amoroso on Pawn Stars (Image source: YouTube/Pawn Stars)

In the episode, the guest brought the guitar, which was designed by the great Gospel musician, Semie Moseley. "Moseley was a great gospel musician, and he founded the Mosite Guitar Company, and I got this guitar directly from  him,  44

years ago," the guest claimed. He shared that it was a prototype called the "Spanish Blue." "He built these flamenco guitars with violin joints, and they had such a remarkable tone that Semie thought gospel musicians should have," he said.

Screenshot showing the guitar (Image source: YouTube/Pawn Stars)
Screenshot showing the guitar (Image source: YouTube/Pawn Stars)

Acknowledging the provenance of the item, Harrison said, "That's extremely interesting." He added that the guitar looked brand new, and since the guest had all the paperwork, it could be an exciting find for his collection. "Jimmy Hendricks, The Beach Boys, Kirk Cain, these are just a few of the guys who have played Mosites. So, if this is the actual gospel prototype, there will definitely be a market for me to sell," Harrison said.

Screenshot showing Harrison looking at the guitar (Image source: YouTube/Pawn Stars)
Screenshot showing Harrison looking at the guitar (Image source: YouTube/Pawn Stars)

When asked about the price of the guitar, the guest said he was looking for about $100,000 for it. Shocked by the asking price, Harrison told the owner that he would need to get it checked by an expert. "It's not that I don't trust you, but you know if I started trusting my customers, I wouldn't be in business for long," he said. He then called in Amoroso of Cowtown Guitars to come take a look at the item and share an estimate of its value. After taking a look at the guitar, Amoroso acknowledged that it was a cool instrument given its history. After examining the item, the expert revealed that it was made in 1967 or 1968, as the serial number on it was GA09.  Coming to the value of the item, Amoroso shared that one similar guitar sold in the range of $35,000 to $40,000 and in the current market, this item would be worth $25,000. 

Screenshot showing the guest's reaction to the appraisal (Image source: YouTube/Pawn Stars)
Screenshot showing the guest's reaction to the appraisal (Image source: YouTube/Pawn Stars)

The number immediately upset the guest, who refused to believe the expert's appraisal. "That's absolutely ridiculous! Because it's been appraised over the years. Back in the '90s, it was appraised at a minimum of $100,000, and that was in the '90s. The guitar has been insured for $100,000 or better," he said. However, Amoroso was confident in his appraisal as he said, "I mean I can insure my shoes for $100,000 with an insurance company." He further added that even the prototypes of Les Paul, the inventor of the solid-body electric guitar, did not go for $100,000 at auctions. 

Screenshot showing Amoroso talking to Harrison and the owner of the guitar (Image source: YouTube/Pawn Stars)
Screenshot showing Amoroso talking to Harrison and the owner of the guitar (Image source: YouTube/Pawn Stars)

But the guest wasn't willing to budge. "I can't agree with your assessment," he told Amoroso. In the end, things got so heated that the expert left the shop in a hurry. "I'm just kind of glad I got out of there without a black eye," he said in an interview. In the end, Harrison trusted the word of the expert and refused to offer anything close to $100,000 for the guitar. Hence, the guest left the shop without a deal.



 

In the end, the owner was still confident that Harrison and his expert were wrong. "I think he just made a huge mistake. I know when it goes to an auction house that recognizes this guitar, I'll probably get 200,000 or more for it," he said.

MORE ON MARKET REALIST
Genius Litter founder Ramon Van Meer impressed the panel and ended up triggering a Shark fight.
1 hour ago
Contestants Danielle Williams and Adam Bencan took the loss in stride, but viewers were enraged.
4 hours ago
Ken Jennings explained what he does differently compared to the show's former legendary host, Alex Trebek.
6 hours ago
Contestant Elizabeth Caprini could've won a brand new Mercedes-Benz, but was stumped by a simple puzzle.
1 day ago
The father-son duo of Miles and Maurice Huffman shared their struggles ahead of negotiations.
1 day ago
While the item was potentially worth $20,000, Harrison admitted he couldn't sell it.
1 day ago
The co-founders of Nutr blew the only chance they had to convince Daniel Lubetzky.
1 day ago
The player, Brandon Rothstein had cracked the puzzle even before the timer kicked off.
2 days ago
Stars from the Real Housewives Franchise, Kandi Burrus-Tucker and Kyle Richards, cracked the host up
2 days ago
Emmitt Smith was happy to authenticate his signature on a photo from his first NFC Championship game.
2 days ago
Melissa Brickey seemed to be caught up in a loop of losing her winnings — until she finally escaped her unlucky streak.
3 days ago
Contestant Pamela's weird answer to a Little Red Riding Hood question caught the host completely off guard.
3 days ago
Speaking to CBS News, Schneider shared how the show made her not care about her looks
5 days ago
With one-letter and sub two second solves, Carmetta Wells put up a great show.
5 days ago
The seller who was hopeful that she could bag a fortune for her thrift store find left empty handed.
5 days ago
Speaking to the LA Times, the "Jeopardy!" host shared personal details on his journey with trivia.
5 days ago
Emotions got the best of Amy Nardin every single time she solved puzzles on the show.
5 days ago
After Harrison found out that the 16th-century book was the real deal, he couldn't let it go.
5 days ago
When the contestants had to name sports teams named after birds, they left the host baffled.
6 days ago
The host opened up about what goes on behind the scenes and in his mind while filming the show.
6 days ago