ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / NEWS

'Antiques Roadshow' guest refuses to sell her family heirloom even if it was 'worth a million'

While the expert on the BBC show did his duty of sharing an appraisal, the guest did not budge.
PUBLISHED JUN 13, 2025
Screenshot showing the guest talking to the expert on the BBC show (Cover image source: BBC/Antiques Roadshow)
Screenshot showing the guest talking to the expert on the BBC show (Cover image source: BBC/Antiques Roadshow)

It's very rare to get a million-dollar appraisal for an item on "Antiques Roadshow," which is why it's surprising when someone doesn't want to part with such an item. Putting sentimental value over monetary worth, one guest refused to let her family heirloom go even for £1 million (~$1.3 million). The guest shared the incredible story of the 19th-century diamond brooch and how it survived the atrocities of World War 2. In the end, the appraiser John Benjamin did his duty of sharing an estimated value of the brooch, which was about £1,000 to £1,500, but he acknowledged that its true value can't be gauged realistically, given its history. 

Screenshot showing the details of the brooch  (Image source: BBC/Antiques Roadshow)
Screenshot showing the details of the brooch (Image source: BBC/Antiques Roadshow)

The episode of the brooch caught the appraiser's eye as it was a remarkable piece of jewelry covered in diamonds. When he looked closely, he found the number 56, which indicated that it had links to Soviet Russia. "The star itself, which is a typical design of the 19th Century, is set with a cluster of white stones, which are diamonds," he explained to the guest. He then asked the guest to share the story of how she acquired the item. He told the guest it was an extraordinary item to have and thanked her for bringing it in, as seen in the video available here.

The owner shared that it was her grandmother's brooch, which had survived Germany's invasion of Poland in 1939. She shared that after 10 days of the invasion, the Russians entered the country from the East, and her family was caught in the middle. “They were trying to reach an aunt's house in Warsaw, Poland, but they were arrested en route by the army. They were accused of being spies and, without trial or any evidence, they were sentenced to five years of hard labor in Siberia," she told Benjamin. 

Screenshot showing the guest talking about the item  (Image source: BBC/Antiques Roadshow)
Screenshot showing the guest talking about the item (Image source: BBC/Antiques Roadshow)

This astonished the expert, who couldn't believe that the guest's family was sentenced to five years of hard labor for doing nothing. The guest added that when her family arrived in the prisoner camp, the men and women were separated, and her grandmother never saw her father again. "For the next couple of years, my grandmother and her mother were moved from camp to camp, and all of their possessions were stolen from them," she shared.

She explained that her grandmother kept the brooch hidden in her cardigan, which she treated like a rag to pretend that it didn't have any value. "It's the only thing left of their life in Poland before the war," she added. She further told the expert that she never intended to sell the item and would eventually pass it on to her daughter, who would carry it forward. "You could tell me it was worth £1 million and I still wouldn't sell it," she said. 

Screenshot showing the guest refusing to sell the item ever (Image source: BBC/Antiques Roadshow)
Screenshot showing the guest refusing to sell the item ever (Image source: BBC/Antiques Roadshow)

Despite the guest's assertion, Benjamin went on to share the appraisal to fulfill his duty. Explaining that the brooch was made of gold & silver and was studded with diamonds, he told the guest that it would be worth around £1,000 to £1,500 (~$1,300 to $2,000)  in the market. However, he added that the item's value went far beyond his appraisal as the piece connected them with the past.

MORE ON MARKET REALIST
Harvey got a genius solution to avoid asking an awkward question to Carson Kressley's family member.
9 hours ago
The player could barely control her excitement as she had a near-perfect game on the show.
10 hours ago
Harrison knew it was too good of a collection to let go, and he decided to raise the stakes.
1 day ago
The guest who had little no idea about his family heirloom was shocked to know its significance.
1 day ago
Despite making a higher than usual offer, Harrison failed to close the deal.
1 day ago
The guest regretted that she wouldn't be able to keep the highly valued item in her home anymore.
1 day ago
They also triggered a showdown between Mark Cuban and Daniel Lubetsky before closing the deal.
2 days ago
As Heather took a second to solve the final puzzle, Seacrest admitted she made it look easy.
2 days ago
Carey suffered a similar snafu a few months ago while playing the same game of 'Bullseye'.
3 days ago
Fans also share some tips that could've helped Bain win the bonus round but it was too late.
3 days ago
Emily Croke coincidentally got the question related to her great-great aunt, Emily Folger.
3 days ago
Luckily for the veteran host, no one in the studio caught the mistake on time.
3 days ago
The executive producer of the show, Michael Davies later apologized for the spoiled show.
3 days ago
Even the seasoned expert was stumped by the unusual subject of the painting.
3 days ago
In the end, Mr Wonderful cut off Greiner with a deal that the founder of Wad Free couldn't refuse.
4 days ago
Seacrest got geniunely spooked as he couldn't figure out who played a prank on him.
4 days ago
The seller brought some "Secret Service" memorabilia of former Attorney General J. Howard McGrath.
4 days ago
The guest was already emotional because of the backstory involving native Alaskans.
5 days ago
The player once again fumbled a puzzle despite moving forward in the game.
5 days ago
The host didn't want to get more of the weird answers on the show anymore.
5 days ago