ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / NEWS

'Pawn Stars' boss Rick Harrison offers $50,000 for a nickel but the seller wasn't impressed

Despite making a higher than usual offer, Harrison failed to close the deal.
PUBLISHED JUL 3, 2025
Screenshot showing Rick Harrison, the coin, and the guest on the show (Image source: YouTube/Pawn Stars)
Screenshot showing Rick Harrison, the coin, and the guest on the show (Image source: YouTube/Pawn Stars)

Rick Harrison, the owner of the store featured on "Pawn Stars," is known for being adamant about bringing the price down during negotiations. But once in a while, he comes across a rare and valuable item that he agrees to pay big bucks for. There was one occasion when the owner of the famous gold & silver pawn shop agreed to pay $50,000 for a tiny nickel. Despite such a hefty offer, Harrison failed to secure a deal as the seller, named Mark, refused to let his 1867 Proof Shield Nickel go, claiming it deserved more.

Screenshot showing Harrison looking at the coin (Image source: YouTube/Pawn Stars)
Screenshot showing Harrison looking at the coin (Image source: YouTube/Pawn Stars)

In the episode, Mark brought the ring to Harrison's table, claiming he had something interesting for the pawn shop boss. "Hey man, I've got a coin I'd like to sell. An 1867 Proof Shield nickel," he told Harrison as he walked in. The veteran pawn star immediately recognized the rare coin as he asked the seller, "Where in the world did you get this?" The guest shared that he had had the coin for about 15 years, and he had it graded and preserved as it was an extremely rare piece.

Harrison acknowledged that the coin was "really neat" before getting into the history of it. "This was just a practical choice. I mean, half dimes were expensive; they were made out of silver. This was a nickel alloy that would last a long time. It wouldn't wear out, and everything else like that. It's a very cool nickel. There are only 25 made," Mark shared. 

Screenshot showing the seller talking to Harrison (Image source: YouTube/Pawn Stars)
Screenshot showing the seller talking to Harrison (Image source: YouTube/Pawn Stars)

Harrison added that the coin was special as it was a proof coin, which meant it was a polished blank coin that was put into the minting machine. "They made sure it was a perfect coin. Proof coins from the 1800s are a rare, rare thing. It could be worth some serious money," Harrison noted. He then asked for the price, and Mark told him that he was looking to get $90,000 for it.

Hearing the number, Harrison decided to call in his expert, David Vagi, the director of NGC Ancients. "It's a fantastic coin. Wow!" Vagi exclaimed as soon as he saw the coin. "Well, this is one of the great rarities in the American series. It's kind of on everyone's checklist who wants something like the 100 greatest United States coins," he told the guest and Harrison.

Screenshot showing the details of the coin (Image source: YouTube/Pawn Stars)
Screenshot showing the details of the coin (Image source: YouTube/Pawn Stars)

Mark then told Vagi that the coin had been in his family for years, and it was significantly rarer than similar ones from 1867. "And when they graded it, they gave it a star, which means it's got really good eye appeal, right?" he asked Vagi. The expert confirmed that the star meant that the coin had exceptional eye appeal. Coming to the appraisal, Vagi estimated that the coin could sell in the range between $63,00 and $80,000.

Screenshot showing Vagi talking about the item (Image source: YouTube/Pawn Stars)
Screenshot showing Vagi talking about the item (Image source: YouTube/Pawn Stars)

Once Vagi left, Harrison got down to business. He asked Mark to share his best price, and he came back with $90,000 again. "I mean, that would be throwing $20,000 away in a heartbeat," Harrison said, before offering $50,000 for the coin. Mark then put his foot down and quoted his final price of $80,000. Unfortunately, Harrison wasn't willing to pay that much.



 

"They offered me $50,000 for the coin. You'd have to be totally in the desert with no water in order to take that offer. He could have had it for $80,000 when it was getting to go for $120,000 or $125,000 in the next few months, probably," Mark said in the end, as he walked away.

More on Market Realist:

'Pawn Stars' boss Rick Harrison geeks out on Val Kilmer's 'Top Gun' jacket and agrees to pay $17,000

'Pawn Stars' boss Rick Harrison comes across a dinosaur bone and ends up paying a fortune for it

'Pawn Stars' boss Rick Harrison had to reject this guest's item because it could 'bankrupt the shop'

RELATED TOPICS PAWN STARS
MORE ON MARKET REALIST
Harrison almost blew the deal for the gold & diamond encrusted ring over $3,000.
11 hours ago
Insulted by her refusal to partner up, Kevin O'Leary told Lori Greiner, 'Do not screw with Mr Wonderful...'
13 hours ago
The witty host reminded everyone that he’s never afraid to deliver the perfect clap back.
1 day ago
TikToker Madilynn Cameron alleged she was asked her to get a membership to use the self checkout facility at Walmart.
1 day ago
The toy train set from the Lionel company turned out to be a invaluable treasure.
1 day ago
The pawn shop boss, Rick Harrison wasted no time to get the mummy authenticated.
1 day ago
The elderly guest was visibly shaken to learn the value of her prized family heirloom.
1 day ago
In an Instagram post, Drew Goldfarb got candid about his big win, friends he made along the way, and things he learnt.
1 day ago
Ken Jennings accidentally let a curse slip and spoiled a clue — and the goof-up made it to air unedited.
2 days ago
The expert admitted that the item wasn't the most appealing thing to appraise.
2 days ago
'Dad had a good day digging,' expert Christian Beadman told the guest after revealing the value of the sculpture.
2 days ago
The guest brought in a rare Alexander Calder sculpture, but she wasn't prepared for the jaw-dropping appraisal.
2 days ago
Cuban, who initially refused to make an offer, jumped back into the competition.
3 days ago
'I've been begging her for this picture ever since I've seen it,' the guest said, recalling how she fell in love it.
3 days ago
With a $1 million prize on the line, Cindy Koenig fell short on a puzzle that many fans felt was quite solvable.
4 days ago
'You blow me away, you're so impressive,' Lori Greiner told the founders, but still lost to Mark Cuban in a bidding war.
4 days ago
Harris still walked away with a good amount of money and a vacation after the game.
4 days ago
'I have to say that I haven't seen very many of these,' expert Bill Harriman said, before revealing its potential value.
5 days ago
This coin survived the Titanic, but it was too expensive for Rick Harrison to bag.
5 days ago
The guest had preserved her great-grandmother's necklace for 35 years, unaware that it was a rare Louis Comfort Tiffany piece.
5 days ago