ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / NEWS

California guy takes his late dad’s old baseball cards to auction. He was in for a massive surprise.

The cards were collected by his father for an entire lifetime even as he moved from one city to another.
PUBLISHED NOV 6, 2024
 A reporter walks past enlarged baseball cards at a Sotheby's preview of a baseball memorabilia sale titled "The Babe Comes Home" November 23, 2004 in New York City.  (Cover image source: Getty Images | Mario Tama)
A reporter walks past enlarged baseball cards at a Sotheby's preview of a baseball memorabilia sale titled "The Babe Comes Home" November 23, 2004 in New York City. (Cover image source: Getty Images | Mario Tama)

It's not uncommon for someone to receive an inheritance in the form of property among other things. But one man from California unlocked a treasure worth millions while he was cleaning his deceased father's closet. John discovered his late father's baseball card collection while cleaning out a cigarette tin in the closet. But, to his surprise, a rare collection of cards featuring some of baseball's historical figures, was gathering dust inside.



 

Collection of a Lifetime

The valuable tin cigarette box that once belonged to a man named Ed was found in a forgotten corner of a house in Tracy. John, whose full name was withheld by the auction house Auction Monthly, said that his father was a longtime collector of baseball memorabilia. When John found the 1900s-era Pedro Cut Plug Tobacco tin, he didn't know what to do with it. He had no idea that the cards in it were some of the rarest and most important baseball cards ever made.

Old sports card collection - (Image source: stock photo/Getty Images)
Old sports card collection - (Image source: stock photo/Getty Images)

John told the auction house that his father Ed lived in Oakland during the early 1920s, and he started collecting the cards in his adolescence. He shared that his father often received baseball cards as gifts from family members, and over the years, his collection grew. Ed kept the cards close all his life, bringing them along from Oakland to the San Joaquin Valley home where they were found. Not long after Ed died, John cleared out the home and discovered the cards just before selling the property. The collection which featured names like Babe Ruth, Ty Cobb, and more, was preserved for more than 100 years.

Representative image of a vintage baseball card collection (Image source:Chris McGrath/Getty Images)
Representative image of a vintage baseball card collection (Image source:Chris McGrath/Getty Images)

Unlocking an Accidental Fortune 

According to the Auction Monthly, most of Ed's collection was formed of cards printed between 1919 and 1926. During this period, the featured players were still in the game and were set to achieve legendary status. Among the 600 cards in the tin, The "1919-21 W514 “Shoeless” Joe Jackson" card in particular is a sought-after item in the market with its value reaching more than $25,000 according to Heritage Auctions. 



 

The collection also included nearly every player from the iconic/infamous 1919 ‘Black Sox’ team, which allegedly threw the World Series in what is regarded as the greatest scandal in sports history as per Fox. In addition to these, the collection also included a 1921 E220 National Caramel Babe Ruth card, a Ty Cobb 1922 American Caramel E121, a 1920 W519 George Sisler, and cards featuring baseball hall-of-Famers Walter Johnson, and Christy Mathewson, among others.

What makes the collection even more rare is that the cards belong to the “Zee-Nuts” set that was available exclusively on the West Coast, according to PreWarCards.com. The Zee-Nut cards are “by far the most complex minor league issue in the pre-war era.”

On the official page, Auction Monthly shared that some of the cards will be sold directly to their clients, while the rarer, high-grade cards will probably be auctioned. The remaining more common and less valuable cards will be sold in a lot through the auction. The firm estimates that the 600-card collection could bring in a "high six-figure" sum.

MORE ON MARKET REALIST
David Malpass told Fox Business that U.S. energy independence will be crucial for growth measures
7 hours ago
Sen. Rick Scott has proposed 'American Dream Accounts' that would help people save for a home.
8 hours ago
The nonpartisan fiscal watchdog CFRB has warned that the U.S. may be heading blindly into the next crisis.
10 hours ago
Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei explains if AI models can actually go rogue and rebel against humans.
10 hours ago
By the end of the game, Harvey was left wondering what he had just heard.
11 hours ago
Senator Cory Booker is set to introduce the new tax with the aim to curb the cost-of-living crisis
1 day ago
Illinois is looking to setup Newborn Equity Support Transfer program to help mothers with childcare
1 day ago
Harvey was disappointed with the players who couldn't come up with the most obvious answers.
1 day ago
Some of the answers were too bizarre even for the seasoned host, Steve Harvey.
1 day ago
While the host fumbled the card, it had just enough for Brenda to win a brand new car
4 days ago
The nonpartisan fiscal watchdog revised its estimates to add $2 trillion to its earlier projection.
4 days ago
Chevron president Andy Walz urged the state's regulators to review their climate policy.
4 days ago
Harvey looked like he had enough as yet another question popped up, targeting him on the show.
4 days ago
Frito-Lay has recalled certain bags of its popular Miss Vickie's Dill Pickle Potato Chips
4 days ago
Americans are paying 26 cents more for gas than a week ago.
5 days ago
Harvey was left holding his stomach after almost every answer the Hunter family gave.
5 days ago
The firm's chief global equities strategist, Peter Oppenheimer, has warned that a correction is imminent.
6 days ago
The suit alleged Tinder charged older users more for its Gold and Platinum subscriptions
6 days ago
The Yoyo Gummy candies are part of an ongoing recall across 14 states over unallowed food dye.
6 days ago
The two progressives estimate the tax would bring in $4.4 trillion over the next decade.
Mar 3, 2026