ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / ECONOMY & WORK

'Pawn Stars' guest was stunned to learn his NASCAR item was a fake — but Rick Harrison consoles him

Rick Harrison did what he could to console the guest who said that he had lost faith in NASCAR.
PUBLISHED JUL 17, 2025
Screenshots showing the guest and the cast of "Pawn Stars." (Cover image source: YouTube | Pawn Stars)
Screenshots showing the guest and the cast of "Pawn Stars." (Cover image source: YouTube | Pawn Stars)

Several guests on “Pawn Stars” turn up with items signed by iconic personalities and sports legends that they look up to. But finding out that the signature is fake on national TV is both heartbreaking and embarrassing. It happened to a guest who brought in a Goodyear NASCAR tire that had legendary driver Dale Earnhardt's signature on it, and would've been precious if it were real.

The guest had several proofs that the tire was indeed part of a car that Earnhardt drove, thanks to the markings made on it by the company. It was a left rear tire from the eighth of the race weekend during which it was used. He produced a certificate of authenticity and another letter by Goodyear confirming that. The issue, however, was that he had no paperwork to back up the authenticity of the signature.

The guest had asked for $1,500 for the tire, which was a fair price as far as Rick Harrison was concerned, if the signature turned out to be authentic. He called in an expert to get it evaluated, and it was Drew, a forensic document examiner with Authentic Autographs Unlimited. At first, it seemed like the tire was authentic. The expert spoke about how the ‘D’ and the ‘L’ of ‘Dale’ were signed just as he’d expected.

Screenshot showing the signature on the tire. (Image credit: YouTube | Pawn Stars)
Screenshot showing the signature on the tire. (Image source: YouTube | Pawn Stars)

The problem was with ‘Earnhardt,’ where the ‘E’ seemed off, and there was a ‘#3’ signed at the bottom of the signature. According to the expert, Earnhardt had never done that while signing autographs. It was therefore ruled a fake. “The ‘Earnhardt’ should be over the mill, you can see how it’s so far to the left. And the capital ‘E’, this should be coming down much further and hooking up toward the capital ‘D’,” The expert said.

Screenshot showing the expert (L) and the guest on
Screenshot showing the expert (L) and the guest on "Pawn Stars." (Image source: YouTube | Pawn Stars)

The guest was devastated to hear that what he had was a fake. Harrison tried to console the guest, but to no avail. Unsurprisingly, no deal was made that day. “I’m really disappointed that it wasn’t the authentic signature from Dale Earnhardt. Lost a little faith in NASCAR today,” he said. As one of the greatest motorsports athletes of all time, it’s no surprise that Earnhardt’s signature is considered precious.

In his time in the top level of the sport, Earnhardt won 76 races, seven Winston Cup Series championships, the Daytona 500, and several other iconic races. His fearless style of driving earned him the nickname ‘The Intimidator’. His death, however, was one of the most tragic in the history of motorsports. It was at the Daytona International Speedway in 2001. He was blocking other drivers on the final lap to help out his son, who was further ahead on the track. It was here that he lost control of his car and suffered a heavy crash, resulting in an untimely and tragic death.

More on Market Realist:

'Pawn Stars' boss Rick Harrison comes across vintage Indy 500 car — but doesn't even make an offer

'Pawn Stars' boss Rick Harrison once called NASCAR legend to authenticate his own tribute car

'Pawn Stars' guest brings a rare 1978 trophy — then the expert says it's 'supposed to be in a museum'

RELATED TOPICS PAWN STARS
MORE ON MARKET REALIST
John considers himself the very best on the show when it comes to licensing deals.
4 hours ago
Fans of the show found the joke tasteless and they let their feelings be known.
5 hours ago
The host was stunned upon hearing the answer and had to ask the contestant about her logic behind it.
6 hours ago
Mr. Wonderful had said no the first time, but promptly came back after learning about the royalty.
9 hours ago
Steve Harvey had a hard time believing the contestant's answer, but she was outdone by her teammate.
1 day ago
The duo worked very well as a team and the victory was well-deserved.
1 day ago
Mr. Wonderful was passionate about bats right from the get-go and was the only one to make an offer.
1 day ago
The pawn shop owner made a deal with the seller that he'd pay more if the gun worked.
2 days ago
Amber Lancaster handled the situation gracefully, and even congratulated the player on his impressive win.
2 days ago
The contestant, Diane, gave a couple of cheeky answers that caught Steve Harvey off guard.
3 days ago
The guest was expecting $22,000 for a Led Zeppelin album that was signed by all four members.
3 days ago
Fans shared their excitement for the upcoming season, with many hoping to see another million-dollar winner.
3 days ago
The host noted that contestant was already a crowd favorite, and his kind gesture made Josh feel like a star.
3 days ago
The item’s uniqueness kept Rick Harrison from making an offer, as there was no reference point for its value.
4 days ago
The entrepreneur 's business was immensely profitable which made her a confident negotiator.
4 days ago
The host did not hold back on his roast, but the contestant took it all in good humor.
4 days ago
The company made sure that pets were well-dressed and taken care of on the owner's wedding day.
5 days ago
The player, Leslie, decided to trust her gut instead of listening to the audience,and it really paid off.
5 days ago
The company had more than $18 million in sales in just the 12 months ahead of taping.
5 days ago
The pawn shop owner did not expect the grinder to be worth so much money.
6 days ago