ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / NEWS

Auction House Sotheby's Faces Allegations of Facilitating Art Fraud; Here's More About the Lawsuit

US judge rules Sotheby's must face allegations in Russian billionaire's art fraud lawsuit, casting a spotlight on a billion-dollar dispute.
PUBLISHED NOV 19, 2023
Italian artist, architect, engineer and scientist Leonardo da Vinci | Stock Montage | Getty Images
Italian artist, architect, engineer and scientist Leonardo da Vinci | Stock Montage | Getty Images

In a world of collectors and auction houses beyond the eyes of admirers, art is serious business. This trade also has its own legal complications, and owing to these, esteemed auction house Sotheby's now faces a lawsuit brought by Russian billionaire oligarch Dmitry Rybolovlev. The art tycoon alleges that the auction house played a role in facilitating a high-stakes art fraud orchestrated by his former art dealer, Yves Bouvier. Facing the scrutiny of a New York federal judge, Sotheby's emerged as a central figure in Rybolovlev's quest for justice. The billionaire, renowned for his collection that includes prized works by Monet and Gauguin, contends that he was overcharged by hundreds of millions for 15 pieces of world-class art.

Pexels | Photo by Riccardo
Pexels | Photo by Riccardo

In a twist that could rival movie plots, the drama revolves around a number of artworks purchased by Rybolovlev between 2003 and 2015, totaling a staggering $2 billion. The focal point of the allegations is Swiss art dealer Yves Bouvier, who not only faces accusations of art theft but also stands accused of inflating the prices of these masterpieces. US District Judge Jesse Furman noted that the evidence could help a jury infer that Sotheby’s assisted Bouvier in obtaining an inflated valuation.

Bouvier, a figure linked to notorious art forgers, faced accusations of stealing famous paintings and was arrested in Monaco in 2015. Rybolovlev's contention revolves around the claim that Sotheby’s played a role in facilitating Bouvier’s alleged fraud. A dozen of the disputed artworks were sold through the auction house, prompting Rybolovlev to argue that Sotheby’s was uniquely positioned to assist Bouvier in manipulating valuations.

Salvator Mundi | Getty Images
Salvator Mundi | Getty Images

The judge advanced Rybolovlev’s aiding-and-abetting fraud claims against Sotheby’s in connection with the sale of other artworks, including Rene Magritte’s “Le Domaine d’Arnheim,” Gustav Klimt’s “Wasserschlangen II,” and Amedeo Modigliani’s “Tête." While dismissing some claims on grounds of timing, the judge urged both parties to consider settling the remaining disputes outside the court, considering the costs and risks associated with a trial. This plea for resolution echoes the broader sentiment that the art world is better suited for the gallery than the courtroom.

Rybolovlev’s relationship with Bouvier soured in 2014 when media reports surfaced about the sale of "Salvator Mundi." The New York Times reported a sale price ranging from $75 million to $80 million, but Rybolovlev claimed he paid $127.5 million for the artwork, alleging a 50 percent markup. The billionaire contends that Bouvier’s markups caused him to overpay by a staggering $1 billion on 38 paintings over 11 years. In his pursuit of justice, Rybolovlev filed criminal lawsuits against Bouvier in Monaco for fraud and money laundering, and similar actions in France and Singapore, where Bouvier’s assets are now frozen. The legal battle reached U.S. shores when Rybolovlev sought documents from Sotheby’s for use in these global lawsuits.

Salvator Mundi | Getty Images
Salvator Mundi | Getty Images

Swiss art broker Yves Bouvier began acquiring artworks for Rybolovlev in 2003, charging a 2 percent commission on each sale. To maintain privacy, Bouvier had little direct contact with sellers, instead representing Rybolovlev's interests through MEI Invest Ltd. or related entities. The intricate web of transactions came to public attention in 2016 when Sotheby’s filed a lawsuit to recoup funds from the da Vinci art sale. Sotheby’s, a prominent player in the art market, argued that it was owed more money from the sale, emphasizing the difference between the reported $80 million and the actual sale price of $127 million. The auction house, which made $3 million on the sale, sought not only financial redress but also wanted to absolve itself of any culpability in the dispute.

"Salvator Mundi” was ultimately purchased in 2017 by an unnamed bidder, later revealed as a Saudi royal who purportedly bought it for the Louvre Abu Dhabi. The intended unveiling at the museum was delayed indefinitely, and the masterpiece has not been seen in public since. As the legal drama unfolds, and the art world watches closely, the ruling by Judge Furman sets the stage for a potentially transformative chapter in the ongoing narrative of high-stakes art dealings.

MORE ON MARKET REALIST
Dwyane 'the Rock' Johnson said that his friend's actions changed the course of his life.
3 hours ago
The Texas inventor pitched a generator named after him on the third season of Shark Tank.
18 hours ago
Despite putting the contestant in an awkward position the host did get the audience to laugh.
1 day ago
Although fans have admired his energy on the episode for years, Paul revealed why he wasn't too happy.
1 day ago
It took more than a decade and an amazing invention for Les Cookson to secure a deal on Shark Tank.
1 day ago
The contestant was also defended by some who said they would've made the same mistake.
2 days ago
While the item received a record-breaking appraisal, a flaw prevented its value from going higher.
2 days ago
She has starred in classic films such as "Sixteen Candles", "The Lost Boys", and "Twister".
2 days ago
What is Judy Sheindlin’s salary per episode? Here’s what we know about the TV judge and her new IMDb TV show, ‘Judy Justice.’
3 days ago
Sajak was criticized by fans on the internet but the contestant clarified that it was just for fun.
3 days ago
Danielle Perez had gone viral after talking about the awkward moment on "The Price is Right" on social media.
4 days ago
The singer also got Malone's number but is only focusing on sharing his work with him for now.
4 days ago
The incident did not bring down the woman's excitement as she kept jumping on stage.
4 days ago
The guest had no idea whose face was engraved on the top of the box and how much it cost.
5 days ago
The young entrepreneur saw a common problem kids his age faced and came up with an invention.
5 days ago
It was a gift from the father of his first client to whom he had sold a condo.
5 days ago
The singer wanted to celebrate his journey by sending fans to the place linked to his early days.
5 days ago
Wait till you hear the list of weird prizes that 'Price is Right' gave in the '50s.
6 days ago
The bottled water from the popular retailer has nanoplastic particles more than the firm's limits.
6 days ago
Most of the sharks had concerns about water pressure even though the product impressed them.
6 days ago