ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / NET WORTH

Here's What the Supreme Court's Scrutiny of SEC's Power Could Mean for the Fight Against Fraud

The court appears poised to potentially curtail the agency's authority, particularly in cases involving in-house administrative law judges, sparking debates about constitutional rights and the reach of government agencies
PUBLISHED DEC 30, 2023
The Florida Supreme Court building | Mark Wallheiser | Getty Images
The Florida Supreme Court building | Mark Wallheiser | Getty Images

In a decisive move by the American Supreme Court, key justices have raised serious concerns about the Securities and Exchange Commission's (SEC) approach to enforcing securities fraud. The court appears poised to potentially curtail the agency's authority, particularly in cases involving in-house administrative law judges, sparking debates about constitutional rights and the reach of government agencies. Here's a closer look at the key arguments and potential implications of this landmark case.

Cover Image Source: GettyImages | Mark Wilson  Staff
 Image Source: GettyImages | Mark Wilson Staff

Conservative justices have expressed reservations about the SEC's use of in-house administrative law judges, suggesting that it might infringe upon an individual's right to a trial by jury under the Seventh Amendment. Chief Justice John Roberts voiced unease about enforcement proceedings lacking both a court and a jury, stating that it seemed "curious" for the government to decide when this right applies. Justice Neil Gorsuch emphasized the foundational nature of the Seventh Amendment, signaling the importance of the right to trial by jury in American society.

Judges also raised concerns about the SEC's increasingly dominant role in enforcement, noting a shift from past decades. Justice Brett Kavanaugh questioned the constitutional perspective of distinguishing between private and government suits.

Image Source: Home Rule News
Image Source: Home Rule News

If the Supreme Court rules that the SEC's method of adjudicating fraud claims violates the Constitution, it could impact other agencies using similar tactics. The Social Security Administration, among others, may face scrutiny, potentially reshaping the landscape of how financial regulatory agencies conduct enforcement actions.

The case in question originated in 2013 when the SEC pursued an enforcement action for securities fraud against George Jarkesy, founder of Patriot28 advisory firm. The SEC utilized an administrative law judge, leading to a penalty of $300,000 and a repayment order of nearly $685,000. Jarkesy contested the proceedings, arguing a violation of constitutional rights.

Pexels | Journalism
Pexels | Journalism

During the Supreme Court arguments, the justices appeared focused on the Seventh Amendment right to a jury. Principal Deputy Solicitor General Brian Fletcher defended the SEC's proceedings, asserting that Congress did not violate the Seventh Amendment by authorizing in-house proceedings.

While liberal justices questioned the limits of challenging these proceedings, a group of administrative law scholars warned of "devastating" consequences if the Supreme Court rules against the SEC. The impact could extend beyond the SEC to agencies such as the Federal Trade Commission, Department of Labor, and the National Labor Relations Board.

Source: GettyImages | Kevin Dietsch  Staff
Source: GettyImages | Kevin Dietsch Staff

Supporters of the SEC argue that flexibility in agency adjudication is essential for addressing complex issues in the regulatory framework. On the other hand, those supporting Jarkesy, including the Chamber of Commerce, see an opportunity for the Supreme Court to reaffirm constitutional limitations on the administrative state.

In a broader context, the case reflects a growing scrutiny of the structure of government agencies by a conservative-leaning majority, questioning the accountability and powers of these entities. As the Supreme Court deliberates, the outcome could reshape the landscape of how financial regulatory agencies enforce securities laws and potentially redefine the boundaries of the administrative state.

This case is not merely a legal dispute; it is a reflection of ongoing debates about the balance of power, constitutional rights, and the role of administrative agencies in shaping and enforcing financial regulations.

MORE ON MARKET REALIST
Here's how much Evans has made after consuming about 3,000 spicy chicken wings on the show.
8 hours ago
Steve Harvey bowed out as a standup comedian after 27 years in 2012, and since then he has been a sought after host.
7 days ago
The man who announced his retirement after the 2023 season was first introduced on television by Oprah.
Dec 3, 2024
Nicholas Puech, who owned a 5.7% stake in the luxury brand, has claimed he has nothing left in bank.
Dec 1, 2024
Pat Sajak has also bagged roles in movies and appeared as a guest host on other game shows.
Nov 20, 2024
The legendary lead vocalist of the celebrated rock band U2 has built a vast empire and is now the second richest rockstar on the planet.
Oct 3, 2024
Trump's impressive car collection includes McLaren Mercedes SLR, Rolls-Royce, and even an exclusive Cadillac.
Sep 27, 2024
The nursing student from Georgia found his trading account balance rise to a whopping $1,309,245,148,628.7
Sep 26, 2024
Is it surprising that the billionaire isn't a frequent shopper at the grocery store?
Aug 31, 2024
The pay gap led to her passing over the role and it ultimately went to a newcomer.
Aug 20, 2024
American businessman Charles Francis Feeney was called the "James Bond of Philanthropy" by Forbes.
Aug 14, 2024
Swift's partner Travis Kelce is estimated to be worth $70 million and the cat is richer than him
Aug 5, 2024
He spent his teenage years earning just $1 per hour by offering tourist tours
May 14, 2024
The rapper earns primarily from album and mixtape sales, endorsements, concerts, tours, live performances, and shows.
May 3, 2024
From real estate mavens and fashion PR queens to content creators and resilient entrepreneurs, these women bring a diverse range of experiences to RHONY.
Apr 27, 2024
For two years, soaring inflation eroded most workers' wage gains but recent data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics suggests that the tide is turning.
Apr 7, 2024
From global show to international tours, delve into the singing maestro Taylor Henderson's net worth
Apr 7, 2024
Today, many artists don't limit themselves to one art form but expand by launching their fashion lines or tieing up with charitable organizations
Mar 24, 2024
Take a look at how the financial maestro Carlos Slim Helubuild himself and his generations a legacy
Mar 24, 2024