ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / ECONOMY & WORK

Costco’s meat is getting returned more often than people realize — Reddit users have thoughts

The retailer has faced a lot of flak lately as people have been shocked and disappointed by its products.
PUBLISHED DEC 22, 2025
Shoppers outside a Costco store (Cover Image Source: Getty Images| Photo by slobo)
Shoppers outside a Costco store (Cover Image Source: Getty Images| Photo by slobo)

Apart from the big discounts, free food samples and a generous return policy, the key to Costco's success is the quality standards that it maintains. But lately, there has been a decline in the quality of certain food products that the retailer sells, and customers have consistently flagged it publicly. Most of the complaints have been against beef and chicken products.

Image Source: Getty Images | Photo By Justin Sullivan
A Costco store. (Image Source: Getty Images | Photo By Justin Sullivan)

According to a report in Mashed, Costco's chicken has been reported to be woody and rubbery, while beef is not properly marbled, contains too much bone, and is not trimmed well enough. Customers even seem to believe that the quality of ribeye has also dropped. While buying food products, especially meat, consumers expect them to be fresh, but Costco has been failing to meet those standards as well.

Shoppers have noted that some of the meat products are spoiled by the time they’ve been purchased. One of them took to Reddit to speak about how the deli turkey they had purchased had already gone bad. "I've been taking back a lot of meat that smells bad before the best-by date. Not sure if it's just a thing at my store, but I'm not paying $60 for a package of meat and throwing it away. It will stink up my fridge for a week,” they wrote in r/Costco.

Dried meat at Costco | (Image Source: Getty Images | Koichi Kamoshida)
Representative image of Costco meat products | (Image Source: Getty Images | Koichi Kamoshida)

The user added that they had emailed the retailer about the spoiled product and had received a gift card a few years ago. In a different Reddit post, another user said that Costco’s chicken is usually pretty bad. But one has to remember that the retailer is not the only one to blame for the poor quality of meat products that customers see on the shelves these days.

How cattle and poultry are raised also makes a lot of difference when it comes to the quality of meat. The Mashed report states that chickens are bred to grow faster, which means that they have a lot of muscle, leading to the chewy, rubbery texture. On the other hand, cattle are often bred on a poor diet, leading to lower-quality meat. About a month ago, the non-profit organisation called Farm Forward released a terrifying study about Costco’s chickens.

(Image Source: Getty Images| Photo by 	Smith Collection/Gado)
The famous Costco chicken. (Image Source: Getty Images| Photo by Smith Collection/Gado)

The retailer is supplied by Lincoln Premium Poultry, and the study stated that the chickens kept at this facility were often held in overcrowded conditions, which led to a lot of these birds suffering from visible injuries. This causes a risk of Salmonella, as the bacterium can be found in poorly handled or cooked poultry. The study also found multiple popular poultry brands had Salmonella levels much higher than federal safety limits in their chickens, and Costco’s supplier was one of those brands.

More on Market Realist:

Costco's holiday schedule could affect customers relying on last-minute shopping

Costco CEO confirms the two major changes announced this year are here to stay

Costco reveals why it’s not raising prices despite inflation — and members will love it

RELATED TOPICS COSTCO
MORE ON MARKET REALIST
This will be damning for the DHS, which is already under immense pressure from the public.
8 hours ago
Experts believe that it has to do with getting a sense of momentary control.
10 hours ago
It seemed like the contestant was heading towards defeat, but his luck soon turned around.
10 hours ago
The company says it has taken action to protect its rights as an importer to seek duty refunds.
13 hours ago
The payout was driven by the company’s financial strength and strong underwriting performance.
14 hours ago
Trump made this claim during his lengthy State Of The Union address earlier.
14 hours ago
Research predicted that in the consumer sector, "AI personalization strategists" and "AI supply-chain analysts" jobs are expected to emerge.
16 hours ago
The product might contain germs as the pasteurization process was not done properly due to a equipment troubleshooting error
1 day ago
The contestant came as close as possible to winning big, but had her heart broken in the end.
1 day ago
Trump failed to address the affordability issue that voters care most about.
1 day ago
He said that society is not quite ready for the pace at which AI is currently displacing workers.
1 day ago
The recall affected products that were sold to customers in four states and in Canada.
1 day ago
Those opposed to the changes believe Trump is politicizing the health of children.
1 day ago
Bessent said that the proposition would be rolled out “in the coming weeks and months,” as a tool for working-class Americans left behind.
1 day ago
“It’s a bad idea. We are very alarmed,” a financial source stated about the proposed move.
1 day ago
A post on X could move trillions of dollars due to the power that retail investors hold
2 days ago
Despite a poor start, the contestant came close to winning the big prize.
2 days ago
The retailer had to face big losses as customers abused the no questions asked return policy.
2 days ago
The President is reportedly looking to pass tax breaks using reconciliation.
2 days ago
"Monetary policymakers would face tradeoffs between unemployment and inflation," Fed governor said.
2 days ago