ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / ECONOMY & WORK

Americans were asked to guess Indonesia's minimum wage. They were nowhere close to it

As it turns out, Americans were highly uninformed about Indonesia's economy.
PUBLISHED AUG 15, 2024
Cover image source: The Indonesian national flag at slope of mount Merapi. Getty Images | Photo by Ulet Ifansasti
Cover image source: The Indonesian national flag at slope of mount Merapi. Getty Images | Photo by Ulet Ifansasti

An Indonesian man living in the US has left Americans baffled. The TikTok creator, Steven Apriliano (@stevenaprilianohas), went viral for asking Americans about the average income of people in Indonesia. As it turns out, Americans were highly uninformed with their guesses missing the mark by thousands of dollars. 

Screenshots from the comments | TikTok | @stevenapriliano
Screenshots from the comments | TikTok | @stevenapriliano

In the video, Apriliano goes around asking different people to guess how much Indonesians earn per month on average. The first person he comes across thinks $5,000 would be the right number. However, the creator hints that it is much lower. The woman then lowers the number to $2,000 and appears to be shocked when the creator says it's even lower. Finally, he tells her that the average income of an Indonesian is just $300 per month or 4,500 Indonesian Rupiah. The woman's jaw drops as she hears the number. 

Screenshots from the video | TikTok | @stevenapriliano
Screenshots from the video | TikTok | @stevenapriliano

Apriliano asks more people who guess different amounts like $3,000, $4,000, or $5,000, and every time the creator tells them the true number, the reaction is the same.

The only person that came closest was a woman who guessed $1,500. The shock is rather natural as $300 seems to be less when compared to the average monthly income in the US, which is over $5,000, according to the latest available data.

The reaction of one woman was probably the most striking. After guessing $3,000 and learning the original number, she wonders how people live there and if they are okay. However, another participant had earlier pointed out that the cost of living must also be cheaper compared to the US.

Screenshots from the video | TikTok | @stevenapriliano
Screenshots from the video | TikTok | @stevenapriliano

While the participant's deduction tends to make sense, the viewers in the comment section made it clear that it is not the case. "they are okay?" no mam we're not okay that's why if I graduate from college I wanna go outside looking for any job. i wont work in my country," expressed user @shy_boy_118.  "crying in pain," added another user @salzzie.

Screenshot from the comments | TikTok | @fd_josh
Screenshot from the comments | TikTok | @fd_josh

Meanwhile, some users clarified that $300 was not the average for all. "$300 only in major cities. if in a small town $150 even less," explained user @good_boywr.

Screenshot from the comments | TikTok | @amaibonbon
Screenshot from the comments | TikTok | @amaibonbon

As per the website ASEAN Briefing, the minimum wage in Indonesia varies across regions. In some provinces, the wage is as high as the creator mentioned but in the majority of places, the minimum monthly wage is much lower. For instance, in the capital, Jakarta, the minimum wage was reported to be 5,067,381 Rupiah or $325 per month in 2024.

However, going further to places like Bali the minimum monthly wage drops significantly to 2,813,672 Rupiah or $180.  Thus, the creator's estimate which shocked the participants in the video, turns out to be rather high or optimistic. 


@stevenapriliano Berapa ya kira2 pendapatan orang di Indonesia menurut orang Amerika ? 🇲🇨🇺🇸 Jumlah penghasilan diambil dari rata2 UMR pekerja tetap / pekerja biasa di Indonesia ya #kerjadiamerika #hidupdiamerika #fyp #fypシ ♬ Monkeys Spinning Monkeys - Kevin MacLeod & Kevin The Monkey

 

For more such experiments, vlogs, sketches, and entertaining content, follow Steven Apriliano (@stevenaprilianohas) on TikTok.

MORE ON MARKET REALIST
Several major companies have pointed to AI as the major factor behind their workforce reductions.
1 day ago
Reports estimate workers will soon push back against losing their jobs to AI.
2 days ago
The contestant came close to winning it all, but her mistake came right at the very end.
2 days ago
The retailer has often brought back items after a long gap, and the strategy usually always works.
2 days ago
From a sales perspective, Walmart has been on top for several years thanks to high revenue.
2 days ago
He believes that only the global elite will benefit from AI's growth on almost every single front.
2 days ago
He claimed that traditional ingredients had been replaced with cheap substitutes.
2 days ago
"So, they will always point the finger at the president and say it's his fault and not take the blame," they said.
2 days ago
"All it took was a president willing to impose tariffs, willing to present manufacturers with the appropriate economic incentives," they said.
2 days ago
The contestant was feeling good about his chances but ended up with nothing.
3 days ago
Several large-scale projects will be undertaken as part of the deal.
3 days ago
Stuart Russel says companies are playing Russian Roulette with humans, and governments should step in.
3 days ago
Healthcare providers cited rising costs and denied reimbursements as the reason for the shortfalls.
3 days ago
The affected products have been recalled as the FDA conducts a full-scale investigation.
3 days ago
The customer had to fight for the product that she was willing to purchase.
3 days ago
“It’s, I think, the worst paper I’ve ever seen in the history of the Federal Reserve system," Hassett stated.
3 days ago
The case is notable as it shifts focus from content responsibility, protected under Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act.
3 days ago
Vance has had varied opinions about the technology in the last year, some good and some bad.
4 days ago
The studio audience loved the segment as they cheered the two on whole-heartedly.
4 days ago
While Warsh compared the current situation with the internet boom, economists differ on the opinion.
4 days ago