ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / NEWS

Mom loses $820,000 claim after her attempted insurance fraud was exposed by her own photo

The court ruled her claims "entirely exaggerated," highlighting the impact of evidence in shaping legal outcomes.
PUBLISHED AUG 22, 2024
Woman's $820K Lawsuit Thrown Out (representative image)  | Unsplash | Photo by Vlad Deep
Woman's $820K Lawsuit Thrown Out (representative image) | Unsplash | Photo by Vlad Deep

Sometimes the most unexpected piece of evidence can expose fraudulent schemes and turn a case around. In one such instance, a woman's substantial injury claim following a car crash has been dismissed by court based on a photograph of her triumph in a Christmas tree-throwing competition, contradicting her claims of severe back and neck injuries.

People discussing Insurance agreement |on Unsplash | Photo by Scott Graham
People discussing Insurance agreement |on Unsplash | Photo by Scott Graham

Kamila Grabska, 36, had filed an $820K injury claim against an insurance company, asserting that a 2017 car crash had left her unable to work or engage in activities with her children for over five years. However, a picture from 2018 turned the tables, as it showed Grabska winning a Christmas tree-throwing competition with remarkable agility.



 

Justice Carmel Stewart presided over the case and deemed Grabska's claims exaggerated after reviewing the compelling evidence, which exposed the contradiction between her reported injuries and the vibrant display of strength seen in the Christmas tree-throwing image. The court ruled that the claims were "entirely exaggerated," leading to the dismissal of the $820,000 claim against the insurance company.

Further evidence that damaged Grabska's case included a video of her engaged in training her Dalmatian in a park. This evidence, along with her admission of winning the Christmas tree-throwing competition, painted a picture at odds with her reported injuries.

Women losses her $820K Claim (representative image) | Pexels| Photo by Reynaldo Brigantty
Women losses her $820K Claim (representative image) | Pexels| Photo by Reynaldo Brigantty

The court learned that Grabska had left her job and was receiving disability benefits, indicating the life-altering impact of the reported injuries. However, the court's ruling hinged on the inconsistency between her claims and the documented activities. The judge remarked that her post-accident pursuits were "completely at odds" with the severity of the injuries she had alleged.

Despite the mounting evidence, Grabska maintained that she had not fabricated her injuries and insisted that her intention was merely to "lead a normal life." However, the court's decision underscored the critical role evidence plays in validating or discrediting injury claims, particularly when such evidence directly contradicts the presented narrative.

This is similar to a bizarre incident echoing elements of insurance fraud, a man in Missouri, USA, allegedly orchestrated a peculiar plan involving the amputation of both his legs to file an insurance claim. The Howell County Sheriff’s Office delved into the case surrounding a 60-year-old resident of Willow Springs, who initially reported losing his legs in a brush hog accident. The man's purported accident lacked the expected gore associated with a brush hog incident.

It appeared that a Florida man had been enlisted to visit the victim wielding a hatchet and intentionally severing his legs, as part of insurance fraud. The 60-year-old, already a paraplegic, seemed to have opted for the amputation, so that he could stage a tractor accident to create a false narrative.

In light of the wasted time and resources stemming from the false report to police and emergency medical services (EMS), the sheriff’s office contemplated pursuing charges against the paraplegic man for filing a false report simply to siphon off money from the insurance firm.

Editor's note: This article was originally published on March 2, 2024. It has since been updated.

MORE ON MARKET REALIST
Speaking to CBS News, Schneider shared how the show made her not care about her looks
10 hours ago
With one-letter and sub two second solves, Carmetta Wells put up a great show.
11 hours ago
The seller who was hopeful that she could bag a fortune for her thrift store find left empty handed.
12 hours ago
Speaking to the LA Times, the "Jeopardy!" host shared personal details on his journey with trivia.
14 hours ago
Emotions got the best of Amy Nardin every single time she solved puzzles on the show.
15 hours ago
After Harrison found out that the 16th-century book was the real deal, he couldn't let it go.
16 hours ago
When the contestants had to name sports teams named after birds, they left the host baffled.
1 day ago
The host opened up about what goes on behind the scenes and in his mind while filming the show.
1 day ago
The player, Ryan Halsey, took the game by storm in the initial rounds but was stumped in the finale.
2 days ago
Sometimes the host of Family Feud just wants the chaos to end as it gets too much.
2 days ago
The show took a hilarious turn when a contestant gave a bold answer that caught the host completely off guard.
2 days ago
Despite talking through her guesses, Carrie Trujillo couldn't crack the puzzle and failed to win $40,000.
2 days ago
Robert Herjavec and Lori Greiner rubbed it in O'Leary's face by celebrating their deal with Phoozy
3 days ago
Duc and Lisa Nguyen's stubbornness paid off, as the co-founders of Baubles + Soles got Daymond John as a partner.
3 days ago
The player got the host to be candid about his fears and his mother's opinion on him.
3 days ago
Justin Baer, founder of Collars & Co., was looking for mentorship from the Sharks in addition to a $300,000 investment.
3 days ago
She said that her husband may still have to buy a dog as America may hold him accountable.
4 days ago
When Harrison knew that the 18th-century map was the real deal, he made a genuine offer.
4 days ago
10 years after her sister’s win, Chelsea Hall hit the jackpot on ‘WoF’ with a brand new Mini Cooper and a cash prize.
4 days ago
The co-founders of BuggyBeds wowed the Sharks so much, they were "itching" to invest, and offered a $250k deal.
4 days ago