ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / ECONOMY & WORK

'Price is Right' contestant doesn't listen to the studio audience — ends up losing three cars

The audience was trying to help her, but she relied on the color of the top she was wearing.
PUBLISHED APR 18, 2025
Screenshots showing the contestant and one of the cars she could have won on "The Price is Right." (Cover image source: YouTube | TPiJ290)
Screenshots showing the contestant and one of the cars she could have won on "The Price is Right." (Cover image source: YouTube | TPiJ290)

Winning big on “The Price is Right” has a lot to do with luck, in addition to skills, which is why it's natural for some contestants to come to the stage with their own superstitions. But one more thing that players have often benefited from is the assistance of audience members. A contestant named Susan, however, chose not to rely on that, even with three brand-new cars at stake. This was a superstitious move, and it cost her a massive prize.

The episode was recorded during the pandemic, so everyone had to keep their distance from each other. Susan won her way to the stage, but there was no physical contact between her and the host, Drew Carey. It was then time to reveal what she would be playing for. The first prize, presented by Manuela Arbelaez, was a Chevrolet Spark. Carey then said that there were some other prizes that she could win as well.

Screenshot showing Manuela Arbelaez presenting the Chevy Spark. (Image credit: YouTube | TPiJ290)
Screenshot showing Manuela Arbelaez presenting the Chevy Spark. (Image source: YouTube | TPiJ290)

James O’Halloran presented the second prize, which was a Hyundai Venue. At this point, the host asked the contestant what she did for a living. Susan said that she worked as a concierge. “You know what she needs to be a concierge, George?” Carey asked his announcer. That’s when the third prize was revealed and presented by George Gray himself. It was a brand-new Toyota Corolla.

Screenshot showing George Gray announcing the Toyota Corolla. (Image credit: YouTube | TPiJ290)
Screenshot showing George Gray announcing the Toyota Corolla. (Image source: YouTube | TPiJ290)

It was then time to reveal what game Susan would be playing. “We’re playing one of our more famous games called One Wrong Price. Now, usually, you play this game for like, you know, washer-dryer, stuff like that. But today we’re playing it for three cars.” The rules of the game are simple. A contestant gets to see the prices of all three prizes and has to guess which one is incorrect. If they’re correct, the player wins everything on display.

Screenshot showing the contestant and Drew Carey on
Screenshot showing the contestant and Drew Carey on "The Price is Right." (Image credit: YouTube | TPiJ290)

Susan was asked to guess which price shown was incorrect. Contestants usually don’t hesitate to take the audience’s help in such situations. The crowd in the studio was already shouting out their answers. However, their calls fell on deaf ears. Susan decided to trust the color of the car and the spirit of Christmas to win the automobiles. The Hyundai was the only car that was red in color, and since she was wearing a red top, Susan decided to choose that as her answer. “I’m gonna go with the red car since I’m wearing red and you’re wearing red,” she said.



 

Unfortunately, her answer was not right, since the Hyundai Venue’s price was not the wrong one, and she should've gone with the Toyota Corolla. Gray and Carey both had screamed the name of the car earlier, perhaps to give a hint to the contestant, but she probably didn’t get it. The choice to trust superstition over people around her cost the contestant dearly.

MORE ON MARKET REALIST
The veteran TV personality has been on the show for over 40 years and has met countless celebrities.
9 hours ago
The guest who made an under $3,000 investment was blown away by the massive appraisal.
10 hours ago
The former contestants shared how things went and their personal interaction from the green room.
12 hours ago
The creator’s concern was that the bread retained its original shape despite being crushed.
13 hours ago
The books were written and signed by one of the most controversial kings in British history.
15 hours ago
While the founder of "Pinblock" got a deal, the terms weren't ideal for him.
1 day ago
As per the expert, the necklace was made in around 1905 and was from the Edwardian era.
1 day ago
The guest who paid $580 for the item was blown away by the 30x appraisal.
1 day ago
The guest believed that the portrait was worth somewhere around $500 and was shocked later on.
1 day ago
Fans were not happy about showcasing a loss on YouTube and social media.
2 days ago
The entrepreneurs even got a couple of sharks to lie down, and they loved the experience.
2 days ago
Herjavec loved the product and understood its potential even when most of his colleagues didn't.
2 days ago
Phil Collen and his band need no introduction as they are considered legends in their genre.
2 days ago
The original version has been ruling TV screens and hearts for decades now.
2 days ago
The guest said that his daughter had purchased them at an estate auction for around $300.
3 days ago
The name inadvertently came from an executive and became iconic for decades.
3 days ago
Culkin has been a clue on the game a whopping 42 times since he was a child star.
4 days ago
The guest was happy with the valuation, and fans got to learn a cool story about a big guitar brand.
4 days ago
The idea of owning human remains, no matter how old, was not something Harrison was a fan of.
4 days ago
The fumble is considered the most epic one on the show in decades of his history.
4 days ago