ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / ECONOMY & WORK

There's a Direct Link Between Migration and Income Taxes, Study Finds

There is a prevailing inclination among Americans to relocate to states offering favorable tax structures.
PUBLISHED APR 4, 2024
Cover Image Source: Representative Image of current federal tax forms | Getty Images | Photo Illustration by Scott Olson
Cover Image Source: Representative Image of current federal tax forms | Getty Images | Photo Illustration by Scott Olson

Despite an overall population growth of 0.49 percent, interstate migration emerges as the primary driver of net population changes at the state level, according to reports. Delving deeper into this phenomenon, a study spanning more than a century of income tax history unveils a compelling narrative: Americans have gravitated toward lower or no-income tax states since the inception of income taxes in 1913. Titled "The Introduction of the Income Tax, Fiscal Capacity, and Migration: Evidence from U.S. States," this pioneering research is co-authored by Ugo Antonio Troiano, economist and associate professor at the University of California.

Employees work relentlessly to make their incomes tax-free. Image Source: Pexels|Photo by Nataliya Vaitkevich
Image Source: Pexels | Photo by Nataliya Vaitkevich

The study marks the first systematic analysis of state income tax implementation in the United States and explores the ramifications of taxpayer migration to lower-tax jurisdictions.

Examining state-level tax policies from 1900 to 2010, the study reveals that states adopting income taxes witnessed a significant increase in revenue per capita, ranging from 12% to 17%. "Personal income tax, initially introduced for wealth redistribution, represents a levy on labor income," explains Troiano, whose expertise encompasses politics and economics.

"The underlying intention was to furnish services to underprivileged segments of the population and mitigate income inequality," he added. However, the research also highlights a persistent trend: escalating taxes have spurred affluent Americans to seek residence in jurisdictions with lower tax burdens.

This phenomenon underscores the delicate balance between taxation and taxpayer mobility. Despite the significance of income taxes for state governments, several states have opted to eschew income taxes entirely, including Texas, Florida, Nevada, Washington State, Wyoming, and South Dakota.

Cover Image Source: Unsplash|Photo by  Leon Dewiwje
 Image Source: Unsplash | Photo by Leon Dewiwje

The study traces legislative battles over income tax implementation, highlighting instances where states either repealed or deferred income tax legislation due to public or political resistance. Moreover, it reveals the pivotal role of interstate migration in shaping tax revenue, economic output, and overall economic growth trajectories.

Furthermore, the 2023 IRS migration data found a prevailing inclination among Americans to relocate to states offering favorable tax structures. Notably, states with below-median state and local tax collections per capita tend to attract strong inbound migration, suggesting a positive correlation between tax policy and population movement.

The impact of interstate migration on states' fiscal landscapes has become increasingly apparent in recent migration patterns. Between 2020 and 2021, post-pandemic dynamics precipitated a large redistribution of taxpayers across state lines, resulting in both gains and losses for various states.

 A tax payer looks at his rebate check | Getty Images | Photo by Spencer Platt
Image Source: A taxpayer looks at his rebate check | Getty Images | Photo by Spencer Platt

New York, in particular, experienced a significant population outflow, losing 1.1 percent of its population to other states between July 2022 and July 2023, according to the U.S. Census Bureau. Aligning with these trends, data from U-Haul and United Van Lines corroborate a broader narrative of shifting population dynamics and migration patterns.

Troiano emphasized that policymakers must remain cognizant of potential mobility responses in the quest to address income inequality. While implementing measures to reduce income inequality is undoubtedly important, it's imperative to recognize that these actions can elicit various behavioral reactions among taxpayers, particularly those in higher income brackets.

"Raising taxes too much might backfire, as the state might lose too many relatively wealthy contributors," he said.

MORE ON MARKET REALIST
Had the contestants not gotten their gamble right, they would have lost everything they'd earned.
14 hours ago
The revelation came thanks to a fan who asked the question during a "Jeopardy!" taping.
15 hours ago
The entrepreneurs' decision came as a big shock to the sharks, and they did not hide it.
16 hours ago
Tina double-guessed her third answer, "Does April have 31 days?" Harvey gave her the stink eye.
18 hours ago
All the theatrics didn't work when sharks started scrutinizing profit margins.
19 hours ago
"Can I stop at any time?" the player nervously inquired. "You can stop any time you want, yes," Carey assured.
20 hours ago
Guests on the show would run with it if they ever got that kind of money on Pawn Stars.
1 day ago
The guest even said to keep the kids in the dark about how valuable these items were.
1 day ago
The company had fantastic sales but a crushing debt with a high interest rate that the sharks hated.
1 day ago
It was only Carey's second season in the show and he could have been part of a massive scandal.
2 days ago
“I won’t say anything, and you know why,” he said, with a gesture to zip his lips.
2 days ago
The ring was rescued by the guest's mother thanks to a stranger early in the morning.
2 days ago
"She blanked out. It happens to the best of us," a fan sympathized with the player.
2 days ago
The instrument originally belonged to the guest's grandfather who suffered a horrific injury.
3 days ago
The contestant's wife seemed embarassed at that point of time, and worried as well.
3 days ago
The co-founders of Dino Don got the shark that they always wanted on board.
3 days ago
One can understand why the measure is in place but the shopper was having none of it.
3 days ago
"My husband and I definitely noticed it! We had to rewind it a few times," a fan reacted.
3 days ago
All of the sharks agreed that she had a great product and the drive to be successful a businesswoman.
4 days ago
It's possible that the dog played a little part in making it easier for them to get a deal.
4 days ago