ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / ECONOMY & WORK

Scientific Research Plagued by Misinformation as Peer Review Fraud Hits Academia

85 similar peer-review reports featuring coercive citation suggest a potential new form of organized academic malpractice known as a review mill.
PUBLISHED FEB 11, 2024
 Cover Image Source: Fraud | Photo by Glenn Carstens-Peters | Unsplash
Cover Image Source: Fraud | Photo by Glenn Carstens-Peters | Unsplash

Scams are affecting consumers, investors, and even those organizing funerals, but apparently, even academic circles are not free from fraudulent schemes. In recent times, academic malpractice involving citation manipulation has been uncovered through a volunteer-led investigation published online by Predatory Reports. The investigation implicated María de los Ángeles Oviedo García, a professor of business management and marketing at the University of Seville, Spain. In academia, the evaluation process for submissions to journals involves peer review, where reviewers rigorously assess each submission against strict criteria to determine acceptance. The investigation was sparked off by a suspicious review report published alongside an article in MDPI’s Journal of Clinical Medicine.

Pexels | Pixabay
Image Source: Pexels | Photo by Pixabay

"[I thought] 'Why is this sentence so clear to introduce these two articles in the introduction section?'" García explains. "Something rang a bell in my head and I thought, I’m going to check it and then I found more and more articles using the same sentence structure. I kept thinking about it and thought there must be something there," she added.

She reportedly discovered a set of 85 review reports across 23 MDPI journals, which were published between August 2022 and October 2023.  According to her, "It was so obvious" and "evident." "The structure was very similar and the content of the review was very similar … the further I dug, the more strange things I was finding – why did no one realize the high rate of self-citation?" she added.

 Anete Lusina | Pexels
Image Source: Photo by Anete Lusina | Pexels

"I thought, 'My goodness, this needs to be exposed – this is fraud in the review process.' It is not a proper review if you repeat the same, for every type of paper, in every type of journal, 85 times," García told Chemistry World. She proceeded to share her findings on X and exposed ten articles that appeared to have been affected by the review mill. 

Anna Pendlebury, publishing ethics specialist at the Royal Society of Chemistry, states that citation manipulation has become a huge problem. "With the presence of paper mills already affecting scholarly publishing, it seems unlikely that this review mill is the only one in existence," she believes.



 

"We are pleased to see that many publishers are working together, alongside associations such as Committee on Publication Ethics and [the academic publishers’ trade association] STM, to combat these significant threats to scholarly publishing," Pendlebury said.

Citation manipulation generally happens when a reviewer attempts to inflate their citation counts for personal gain or any other reason. Tens of thousands of sham research papers are becoming a reality, prompting scientists and investigators to look into it. 

These scams are compromising medical research to a significant extent, resulting in research fraud. According to Professor Dorothy Bishop of Oxford University, "The situation has become appalling." "The level of publishing of fraudulent papers is creating serious problems for science. In many fields, it is becoming difficult to build up a cumulative approach to a subject because we lack a solid foundation of trustworthy findings. And it’s getting worse and worse," she said.



 

According to The Guardian, this scam has its roots in China, where young doctors and scientists are seeking promotions. Organizations like, "paper mills" have begun to supply fake and fabricated work. The scam has since been witnessed in different countries like Iran, Russia, India, and, Eastern Europe.

MORE ON MARKET REALIST
The contestant said she was bad at it but there is no excuse for mistaking a continent for a country
15 hours ago
Corey Harrison did not know much about the jersey, but he got a lot of help from the expert.
18 hours ago
The contestant would have become the first man to achieve the big prize.
19 hours ago
The question was about some of the most popular boy bands of all time.
1 day ago
The guest did not create a fuss but was adamant about the authenticity of his item.
1 day ago
The host's speech made for a sombre moment but he found a way to make that funny as well.
1 day ago
Fans once again called out the puzzle, which, according to them, was too tough.
2 days ago
The guest wanted a five-figure sum at first but was left disappointed by Harrison's stubbornness.
2 days ago
Rick Harrison was not as careful with this item as one would have expected him to be.
2 days ago
The contestant got a couple of chances to answer, and Harvey was left unimpressed on both occasions.
2 days ago
The contestant has denied the host's claims on social media that has fans intrigued.
2 days ago
It must have felt like a full circle moment for the family that had felt similar emotions back then.
3 days ago
The entrepreneur did not have a clear plan to grow the business despite having such a big ask.
3 days ago
All of the other sharks said no due to the risks, but Cuban seemed eager to take the gamble.
4 days ago
The contestant started the game strong but had to wait until the end for the big win.
4 days ago
The contestant faced a tough puzzle and she was not prepared for that at all.
4 days ago
Cuban had seen enough of Mr. Wonderful's greedy tactics, and he decided to take a stand.
5 days ago
Fans were also left as confused as the contestant after seeing the puzzle.
5 days ago
The iconic "Jeopardy!" champion has been hosting the show for many years now.
6 days ago
The host remembered the times he was bullied as a young kid after hearing the chant.
6 days ago