ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / ECONOMY & WORK

Shopper finds an odd smell in Costco bottled water and warns others to be careful: "It smells like..."

Costco might be one of the biggest supermarket chains but that's not going to save it from criticism.
PUBLISHED FEB 11, 2025
Screenshots showing the bottled water from Costco in question. (Cover image source: TikTok | @quantum.jedi)
Screenshots showing the bottled water from Costco in question. (Cover image source: TikTok | @quantum.jedi)

In addition to the recalls of products such as eggs and meat over contamination risks, as well as the displeasure caused by membership verification at its store, Costco is also facing trouble from consumers calling it out for inferior quality products on social media. This time, something as basic as water from Costco is under the scanner and TikTok user @quantum.jedi recently uploaded a video on the platform about it. She alleged that the bottled water which she bought from the supermarket chain smelled funny. This is a cause for concern as unclean water can lead to diseases that in some cases might even be fatal.

In the video, a man could be seen taking out a bottle of water from a package of several such bottles. He opens the cap, smells it, and is instantly revolted. “What’s going on @costco ?? The smell burns your nose,” the caption of the video read. There are several reasons why water could smell funny and none of them are healthy.

Screenshot of the man after smelling the Costco water. (Image credit: TikTok | @quantum.jedi)
Screenshot of the man after smelling the Costco water. (Image credit: TikTok | @quantum.jedi)

“Alright, so we’re smelling the Costco water because it smells like dog water. It smells like dogs. Not all of them do but some of them do. Trying to figure this out,” the TikTok user said in the video. “Smells like dog, wet dog,” she added. Most people are aware of what a wet dog smells like and if water smells like that, it clearly isn’t fit for consumption. Viewers also chimed in with similar experiences with Costco-bought water.

“Lol the machinery used to bottle water is NEVER cleaned. Bottled water is absolutely disgusting,” one user called @soficating commented. “I’ve noticed it too, seems to come from the cap / drinking part of the bottle it’s so gross,” quipped another user named @Bobo.


@quantum.jedi What’s going on @costco ?? The smell burns your nose #waterqualityfail #bottledwater ♬ Oh No - Kreepa

 

It turns out that normal water isn’t the only thing from Costco that has disappointed customers. Their alkaline water also doesn’t have the best reviews. TikTok user @vianht05 purchased it and tested it to see if the product was what it was advertised to be. Alkaline water has a pH level of more than 7 and it is supposed to improve hydration, and Costco claimed that the pH level in its product was 9.5

When the TikToker bought some pH strips to test the water, the pH level came to be 6. This was not even more than 7 which is required for alkaline water. “I ended up finding out that for the Costco water, the pH was at 6.0,” she said. “And the total alkalinity was at a zero. I guess that’s why they have the disclaimer on here, pH 9.5 at the time of bottling.”

Viewers joined the chorus of criticism in the comments section of the video. “I’ve heard once you put pH water in plastic it cancels out the pH,” one user called Michelle Nicole commented. “Something about when you open it it’s no longer at the same pH and it’s all alkaline water not just Costco… it’s pretty much a gimmick,” quipped another user.

For more such content about Costco, follow @quantum.jedi on TikTok.

MORE ON MARKET REALIST
The current price of the item is $16.99, which is several times higher than the $9.99 it used to be.
55 minutes ago
Fans were clearly not happy after two straight losses in the Bonus Round.
18 hours ago
Costco one is sold for a premium price, making it a lot less affordable than the Walmart one.
19 hours ago
The retail giant would not want one of its best seasonal products to remain unsold.
21 hours ago
This move would severely hurt businesses and consumers will have to pay a lot more.
23 hours ago
The contestant was momentarily disappointed, but she was happy to have won more than $17,000.
1 day ago
Those interested can avail the Walmart Plus membership for $49 instead of the usual $98 for a year.
1 day ago
No one saw this coming, but it doesn't mean the product won't return to the shelves again.
1 day ago
Several businesses are offering free meals to current and former military personnel on November 11.
1 day ago
Emmer believed that the President had inherited a broken economy from the previous administration.
2 days ago
With the holiday season right around the corner, the company wants to bring in big revenue.
2 days ago
The retailer has some great discounts in store for the holiday season this year.
2 days ago
It's not the best look for ByHeart, the company producing and selling the baby formula.
3 days ago
She had won more than $30,000 leading up to the Bonus Round, which was a great feat.
5 days ago
The bird's stock in the US is the lowest of the last 40 years thanks to a deadly avian flu.
5 days ago
The company claimed that there were concerns about physical safety with the bottles.
5 days ago
Currently, arguments about the legality of the President's tariffs are being made and heard.
5 days ago
She composed herself just well enough to be able to thank host Drew Carey after her big win.
5 days ago
The contestant was flexing his muscles and the host might have taken offence at that.
6 days ago
A lot of people would have wanted to swat the creature had it sat on their bodies out of fear.
6 days ago