ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / NEWS

Employer Not Responsible for Virus Spread to Employee's Family, Says Supreme Court of California

The U.S. Chamber of Commerce and other businesses also said that these cases and lawsuits can successfully "cripple the businesses in California."
UPDATED JUL 19, 2023
Cover Image Source: Pexels | Andrea Piacquadio
Cover Image Source: Pexels | Andrea Piacquadio

The Supreme Court of California recently ruled that employers are not responsible for any virus that has been caught in the workplace and later spread to a family member of an employee. A woman from California claimed that she was infected with COVID-19 after her husband contracted the virus at the San Francisco construction worksite back in 2020. The woman later sued the company for their negligence on the work premises. An attorney with Hinshaw and Culbertson in San Francisco who represented the company said that the employer does not owe a duty of care under California law to prevent the spread of COVID-19 to employees' household members, per Coventus Law.

Pexels | Sora Shimazaki
Image Source: Sora Shimazaki/Pexels

This is true even if the company showed signs of negligence by failing to stick to the health and safety guidelines. “In some cases, ‘the consequences of a negligent act must be limited to avoid an intolerable burden on society,’” Justice Carol Corrigan wrote in the ruling. The ruling is also applicable to other diseases like flu, RSV, and more. If the companies were held liable for these infections, it could potentially shut down businesses and "overwhelm the courts in trying to parse out who had a valid claim and who didn't," he said. This ruling came as a win for not only Victory Woodworks Inc. but for all the major employers and businesses. 

Pexels |  Vanessa Garcia
Image Source: Vanessa Garcia/Pexels 

The U.S. Chamber of Commerce and other businesses also said that these cases and lawsuits can successfully "cripple the businesses in California," as per LA Times. The court warned that imposing such duties on the company toward the household members of the employees could lead to an excessive burden on the judicial system. Having said that, the court asked the workplaces to be cautious about spreading communicable diseases.

Corby Kuciemba, the wife of the employee who sued the company, has refused to comment on the court's ruling as of now. However, her attorney, Martin Zurada said that they were disappointed with the court's ruling but thanked the "justices for their time and consideration."

The pandemic led many employees to file workplace lawsuits in state and federal courts, as per  Chicago-based law firm Seyfarth Shaw. Out of the 1000 cases, more than 200 were related to workplace safety where the workers claimed that the businesses didn't take proper measures or invest in hygiene products. The general duty clause of the Occupational Safety and Health (OSH) Act of 1970 requires that employers provide a work environment "free from recognized hazards that are causing or are likely to cause death or serious physical harm," per SHRM.

Pexels | Anna Shvets
Image Source: Anna Shvets/Pexels 

In 2020, OSHA issued citations that resulted in more than 250 inspections and $3.8 million worth of penalties. The Occupational Safety and Health Administration needs workplaces to establish an environment that will be free from any recognized hazards that may cause serious physical harm or even death. "Employers in high-hazard industries, those with employees working with asbestos or toxic chemicals, may remain especially vulnerable to third-party claims," said Lori Ocheltree, a San Francisco attorney, per SHRM. 

Personal Injury Lawsuits: Businesses need to create a safe and healthy environment for their workers and failing to adhere to the guidelines can result in these lawsuits.

Negligent Security Issues: A business is legally responsible for creating an environment that doesn't promote the transmission of viruses or other communicable diseases, steps to avoid a mishap may include crowd controlling and other such actions.

It's important to make sure that no contract was breached because of COVID-19, so companies need to continually revise policies. A great example would be flight refunds that were not smoothly received by passengers after their flights got canceled due to the pandemic.

MORE ON MARKET REALIST
One of the customers contacted her employer after receiving her wage twice, and soon realized it was an error.
7 hours ago
She first bought 20 tickets and then went back to buy 10 more after she had an intuition.
10 hours ago
In an attempt to surprise Sandler, Spade ended up being more generous than he planned.
1 day ago
The man's presence at a women-only poker event also sparked a huge online debate.
1 day ago
He revealed that the piece of advice that changed his outlook toward money came from a celebrity business manager Lester Knispel.
1 day ago
The workers chose to stick to the company's core values and did the right thing.
2 days ago
The guest revealed that she didn't know about the trade mentioned on the disk when it was purchased.
2 days ago
The CEO at the local casino decided to make her birthday even more special by adding a gift to her winnings.
2 days ago
Sometimes things that don't shine turn out to be worth more than gold.
3 days ago
Spending on restaurants and hotels increased by 0.3 percent in May which was the single largest influence.
3 days ago
The Hollywood star said, "I've left more money on the table than any actor actually."
3 days ago
Many are now heading to the shop from far beyond the county to try their luck.
3 days ago
The duo also performed a cover of Adam Jenson's 2017 song “Street Fight”.
3 days ago
Pam, 83, said "I could have made a fortune, but it wasn’t to be. I’ve had a happier life than Marilyn ever had. I’ve no regrets."
4 days ago
Early 1980s was a special era as several rare coins were minted then.
5 days ago
According to reports, the fisherman from Puerto Princesa found the item over a decade ago while he was fishing in the sea.
5 days ago
For decades, the painting was hung in a shabby frame in the living room.
5 days ago
The asteroid was discovered by Italian astronomer Annibale de Gasparis on March 17, 1852, who named it after the Greek Goddess of the soul.
5 days ago
In the video, another friend can be heard gasping and noting how she thought that Maddie was 'exaggerating.'
5 days ago
The man from New Jersey who was looking to save a few bucks, didn't know what luck had in store for him.
6 days ago