ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / ECONOMY & WORK

'Antiques Roadshow' guest struggles to breathe after expert revealed the value of her oil portrait

She had no idea who the painter was and what it might be worth, so her shock was understandable.
PUBLISHED APR 25, 2025
Screenshots showing the expert and the guest on "Antiques Roadshow" (Cover image source: YouTube | Antiques Roadshow PBS)
Screenshots showing the expert and the guest on "Antiques Roadshow" (Cover image source: YouTube | Antiques Roadshow PBS)

Art is passed on and preserved as an inheritance through generations, but at times, those who get it from their relatives don't realize the significance behind a painting or a sculpture. When a woman showed up on “Antiques Roadshow” with a painting lying around in the house, she had no idea who the artist was. But when she learned about the story and value of the painting of a Native American woman, the guest couldn't stop her tears.

The woman's father-in-law used to work as a boilerman for the Carnegies of New York City, and this painting used to be in the Carnegie mansion. After Mr. and Mrs. Carnegie passed away, their daughter, Mrs. Miller, gifted the painting to the guest’s father-in-law. This was in 1946, the same year her husband was born, and he had been seeing it in his house ever since he was a kid.

Screenshot showing the guest on
Screenshot showing the guest on "Antiques Roadshow." (Image source: YouTube | Antiques Roadshow PBS)

However, he did not know who the painting was by. The guest said that she had moved a couple of years ago, and the painting had been in storage since then. She had forgotten to look at it and was surprised when she saw that it was of a woman. “I was surprised that it was a woman and not a man because that was my memory,” she said. It was now expert Tony Abeyta's job to educate the woman about the value of the art that she possessed. The first thing that he noticed was that the frame was original. The painting had never been taken out of it, which meant that it was in its original form. Abeyta then said that the subject was most likely a Taos Indian, who are Natives of the city of Taos in New Mexico.

Screenshot showing the expert and the guest on
Screenshot showing the expert and the guest on "Antiques Roadshow." (Image source: YouTube | Antiques Roadshow PBS)

The expert then revealed that it was an oil painting that was done with a model who posed for the painter. He also figured out that it was made sometime in the year 1900. Back then, painters from all over the country came to the Southwest, which had a Taos Art Colony. “You don’t have a signature or anything on the painting?” he then asked the guest. When she said no, the expert proved her wrong. “When I first saw it, I knew exactly who painted it,” Abeyta said. “All I had to do was look behind the dust in this area in here.” The words JH Sharp were written there, but a keen eye was required to figure that out. The full name of the painter was Joseph Henry Sharp, an Ohio native who is one of the most important artists when it comes to Taos Indian art.



 

It was then time to appraise the exquisite painting. Given the fact that it was in its original frame, never been taken out, and in fantastic condition, Abeyta believed that it could bring between $50,000 and $70,000. This was a lot more than what the guest was expecting, and she could not hold back her tears. “I can’t believe it. That’s amazing,” she said, tears in her eyes.

MORE ON MARKET REALIST
The guest wanted more than $3,000 for the item but the expert crushed his hopes.
14 hours ago
The game even had a twist which saw Drew Carey doing something special for the contestant.
15 hours ago
One had to pay attention to catch the error, and the show has a lot of fans like that.
16 hours ago
The contestant's nonchalant behavior after answering left everyone on the show stunned.
17 hours ago
The host was left red-faced and he even apologized to the contestant later on for his actions.
1 day ago
The guest was not expecting the low valuation of his item given by the expert.
1 day ago
The host perhaps did not expect to hear that answer and was left impressed.
1 day ago
The contestant was over the moon with her victory, which she made look quite easy.
2 days ago
The guest could do nothing more than accept his bad luck, and that is exactly what he did.
2 days ago
The host had his head down and could not even look at the board as the answer was revealed.
2 days ago
Almost all of the answers given were either shocking or hilarious, or both.
3 days ago
The pawn shop owner had doubts about the beverage's condition and was proven right.
3 days ago
The pawn shop owner has always been a big fan of WWII memorabilia and this was no different.
4 days ago
The contestant turned to the audience for help and it paid massive dividends.
4 days ago
None of the three contestants wagered anything in the final round, which was a first.
4 days ago
Cuban was excited to try them on and did a good job despite not having too much experience.
4 days ago
The contestant, Christina Derevjanik became the biggest winner ever in the show's history.
5 days ago
The guest reduced his asking price by $40,000 and it still wasn't enough to convince Harrison.
5 days ago
The contestant had her mother and sister with her, both of whom were also emotional.
5 days ago
Fans made their opinions clear under an Instagram reel posted by the show's official handle.
5 days ago