ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / ECONOMY & WORK

'Antiques Roadshow' guest says 'holy smokes' after expert reveals the value of her Olympic collection

Al Oerter won four consecutive Olympic gold medals between 1956-68, breaking and setting a new record each time in the discus throw.
PUBLISHED APR 19, 2025
1956 - 1968 Al Oerter Olympic Collection on 'Antiques Roadshow' 2025. (Cover Image Source: YouTube | Antiques Roadshow PBS)
1956 - 1968 Al Oerter Olympic Collection on 'Antiques Roadshow' 2025. (Cover Image Source: YouTube | Antiques Roadshow PBS)

Most guests on "Antiques Roadshow" bring heirlooms passed on to them by elders, while they know little of their origins. But once in a while, relatives of well-known personalities or people who knew them bring items that they know all about, but are still astonished by their true value. American discus thrower Al Oerter is rightfully deemed an Olympic legend for his extraordinary athletic feat. He won four consecutive Olympic gold medals between 1956-68, breaking and setting a new record each time in the discus throw. He achieved the distinction of being the first athlete to throw beyond 200 feet (61 meters) in 1962, according to the Olympics official site. Despite knowing all this, when one of his daughters presented his Olympic Collection on "Antiques Roadshow" for appraisal, she was stunned and exclaimed, "Holy smokes!" Gushing about her father's legacy, the guest said, "We just love talking about our dad. Many people don't know about him because discus, who knows about discus? So, to kind of bring it up again is really a great feeling."



 

"We brought in my dad's four Olympic gold medals, and some memorabilia, and a discus. He won four consecutive gold medals in discus in '56,  '60, '64 and '68, so we had those medals," she continued. She then went on to give a brief sports history about her father's medals, "Each medal really did represent something, like his first medal, he was way too young, shouldn't have been there, but he won. And then in two other games, he was injured, shouldn't have been there, and he won. And in 68, he kidded around saying he was too old and shouldn't have been there, but he won," she nostalgically recalled.



 

Oerter's journey as a legendary Olympian was, however, marred by several serious injuries. Right before competing in the 1960 Olympics, he met with a devastating accident, which required him to wear a neck brace to protect his injured cervical disc. As a result of intense training, he tore a rib muscle just before the Tokyo games. Not heeding medical advice, the ace sportsman turned during the game, wearing a neck brace and carrying ice packs. He set a new record that day and also won his third gold. However, the strenuous effort messed with his physical capacity as a player. Oerter had to be lifted off the field, thus ending his chance to compete in the sixth and final throw.

1956 - 1968 Al Oerter Olympic Collection on 'Antiques Roadshow' 2025. (Image Source: YouTube| Antiques Roadshow PBS)
1956 - 1968 Al Oerter Olympic Collection on 'Antiques Roadshow' 2025. (Image Source: YouTube| Antiques Roadshow PBS)

Oerter retired from the game in 1968 and took over the management side of the sports. An abstract artist himself, he also co-founded the Art of the Olympians program, an initiative that promoted artworks of fellow Olympians. Coming back to his memorabilia, his daughter never imagined that they would be valued so highly by Leila, an antique appraiser. "I was really hoping I would get Leila because I've seen her on the show, and she's so enthusiastic, and so freaking smart. And when she walked in and walked to our table, I was so excited," Oerter's daughter exclaimed. 



 

After evaluating the history and the condition of the Olympic collection, the appraiser revealed the value. "I would place an insurance value on the whole collection here at $400,000," she said. "Are you kidding? Holy smokes. Wow, that's impressive. Wow," the Olympian's daughter reacted. "We are going to put them back in a safe and not let kids play with them anymore," the guest concluded.

MORE ON MARKET REALIST
The founder had lost a lot of money due to bad decisions before and did the same again.
5 hours ago
Contestants do tend to commit blunders under pressure amidst the energy on the set.
6 hours ago
His father was not happy that he overpaid and made it crystal clear to him later on.
7 hours ago
They called their product the future of real estate, and almost every single shark bought into it.
10 hours ago
Rick Harrison has been wrong about some items in the past, and once even doubted himself.
1 day ago
Fans of some shows can be quite brutal in their assessment and they don't shy away from expressing it.
1 day ago
Ken Jennings might be extremely smart, but even he had to concede defeat to technology more than a decade ago.
1 day ago
While most Sharks were out, the founder of Dirty Cookie, Shahira Marei, found her perfect partner.
1 day ago
Some entrepreneurs need a little push and there's no one like a mother to do that.
2 days ago
The player effortlessly swept the game and Carey was impressed but couldn't respond to the offer.
2 days ago
Richard Benjamin Harrison was very impressed with what the guest had brought to the show, but remained calm.
2 days ago
Jennings is a legend of the game himself and he has a lot of respect for other successful players.
2 days ago
Harrison was ready to make 'the biggest buy in Pawn Stars history' for the item.
2 days ago
This wasn't the first time that fans were upset about contestants not recognizing a well-known personality.
3 days ago
The watch was sold four years after it came to the show for a massive amount of money.
3 days ago
Many fans also mentioned how they were themselves unable to solve it.
3 days ago
Things could have ended up quite nasty had he connected his boot with the host's face.
3 days ago
One of the things that made the record so valuable was the signature of a late, great drummer.
4 days ago
No one expects to see someone intentionally drop their phone in the toilet, but that's what we got.
4 days ago
The experts were certainly intrigued as they had probably never appraised a food item before.
4 days ago