ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / NEWS

United Airlines once faced a $180 million loss. All they did was refuse to pay for a broken guitar

The incident damaged the airline's reputation causing a 10% drop or a $180 million loss in the stock market.
PUBLISHED SEP 28, 2024
Cover image source: Photo by ViewApart | Getty Images (Representative)
Cover image source: Photo by ViewApart | Getty Images (Representative)

One man brought a big airline nearly to its knees by going beyond the traditional customer service counter. Back in 2009, when United Airlines mishandled Canadian singer Dave Carroll's luggage and broke his guitar, the baggage handlers probably didn't think it would cost millions. Carroll, who got fed up with the poor customer service of the airline, decided to make a diss track with his band, triggering a PR disaster for the airline. As his music video went viral, it has over 23 million views, the airline's stock plummetted by over $180 million, as per Times Online


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by Dave Carroll (@davecarrollmusic)


 

It all started in 2008, when he was flying from Halifax, Nova Scotia to Omaha, Nebraska for a show with his band “Sons of Maxwell.” They boarded a connecting flight which had a stop in Chicago. In conversation with Marketplace, Carroll shared that while deplaning at the airport, he heard a woman go "Oh my God, they’re (baggage handlers) throwing guitars outside." 

Backstage sound equipment case | Getty Images |  stock photo
Backstage sound equipment case | Getty Images | stock photo

In his music video, he explained the same story saying that when he brought it up with the airline workers in Chicago, they brushed him off. He told the publication that they even said this is why he had to sign a waiver. When the band finally got to Omaha, his $3,500 Taylor guitar had a large hole in it and was badly damaged. Since it was late in the night, he couldn't find anyone at the service desk either.

Next, he called the 1-800 number of customer service, starting a nine-month-long and frustrating journey.  Carroll said he had bounced around and hung up several times ultimately landing in the email of an executive named Ms Irlweg. By this time, he had already got his guitar repaired for $1,200. 

Woman in call center on phone | Getty Images |  stock photo
Woman in call center on phone | Getty Images | stock photo

After exchanging dozens of emails, Ms Irlweg, who is named in the diss track, told him that his request for vouchers worth $1,200 could not be fulfilled as he did not file a claim within 24 hours. Carroll shared that he wrote in response that if he were a lawyer he would sue the company. But since he was a musician, he only had music at his disposal. 

Carroll then gathered all his resources and friends to make three diss tracks against the airline, thinking he may get a million hits on YouTube on all of them combined.  He knew that it would resonate as almost everyone in the industry had faced a similar problem. 

Thus, with a tiny budget, they shot the first music video titled "United Breaks Guitars". Before posting the video on YouTube, he messaged all of his Facebook friends to watch the video, once it went live.



 

While Carroll wasn't expecting much, the video went viral and amassed thousands of views within hours and a million in four days. As it breached the 10 million mark, Carroll had already grabbed widespread media attention.  

Following a wave of international press coverage and nearly 10,000 emails from people across the globe, “United Breaks Guitars” became the number-one music video in the world for a month. The attention even got Carroll endorsement deals from guitar case companies and a call from Bob Taylor from Taylor Guitars.



 

While Carroll became a sensation, United Airlines faced a PR disaster. The Times of London reported that the incident had damaged the airline's reputation causing a 10% drop or a $180 million loss in the stock market. Quite obviously, United reached out to Carroll and offered him the $1,200 vouchers plus $1,200 cash for his troubles. However, Carroll had gained much more with his newfound fame.

MORE ON MARKET REALIST
The player Titus Stevens missed out on taking home nearly $65,000 over an easy puzzle.
6 hours ago
Harvey couldn't control himself after hearing some of the answers.
7 hours ago
The thrift store find turned out to be quite profitable for the seller named Kimberly.
1 day ago
The creator showed proof that the store jacked up the price of an item by $3 during a sale.
2 days ago
The contestant, Linda Rivera failed to crack a seemingly easy phrase in the finale.
2 days ago
Fans couldn't believe that the player chose to miss out on such a good opportunity.
2 days ago
Host Drew Carey had to point out how loud the viewers were before the emotional victory.
3 days ago
While the guest got a massive appraisal for her grandma's ring, she was clear on her stand.
3 days ago
While some blamed the tough puzzle, a few were disappointed with the player, Rob Schwandt.
3 days ago
The player was a bit too excited for the trip and so was her husband in the audience.
4 days ago
The player, Ashton Hildebrand when on to win the showcase for prizes worth over $52,000.
4 days ago
The guest, Jad managed to bring a deal back from the dead and get exactly the amount he asked for.
4 days ago
While some players played it safe, others destroyed their marriages on the show.
4 days ago
Harvey was sure tha the player, Darren didn't want to be on the show at all.
5 days ago
The unexpected collaboration aims to solve a long-standing home surveillance issue.
5 days ago
The co-founders of Y'all Sweet Tea blew away the Sharks with their incredible numbers.
6 days ago
From his lips to his bald head, Harvey has to defends all sort of jabs.
6 days ago
The woman who gifted the painting to the owners had earlier sold it to another dealer as she couldnt sleep at night.
Oct 6, 2025
When it came to naming something of Harvey they would want to touch, the players didn't hold back
Oct 6, 2025