ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / ECONOMY & WORK

Costco shoppers reveal the item that makes memberships worth it — it's not what you'd think

"Best sliced aged white cheddar in the market that’s farmer-owned and uses zero hormones, zero RBSt, and zero GMO in dairy," a user wrote.
PUBLISHED FEB 5, 2026
People with shopping carts filled with groceries walking out of Costco store in Virginia (Cover Image Source: Getty Images | Photo by krblokhin)
People with shopping carts filled with groceries walking out of Costco store in Virginia (Cover Image Source: Getty Images | Photo by krblokhin)

Perks such as attractive deals and generous return policies offered by Costco convince customers across America to spend on its membership. There are several items popular at its food court and in the frozen meat section, from the $1.50 hotdog and soda combo to the rotisserie chicken. But now loyal customers of the retail giant have revealed a dairy item, that makes Costco memberships worth spending on for them.

Tillamook Cheese at Costco (Image Source: Getty Images | Photo by Kevin Carter)
Tillamook Cheese at Costco (Image Source: Getty Images | Photo by Kevin Carter)

Regular Costco customers have rated the Tillamook block cheese highly, as the price of a 2.5-pound block of Tillamook Medium or Sharp Cheddar is approximately $11.23. Compared to rivals like Walmart (39 cents), Kroger (62 cents), and Target (55 cents), Costco sells these cheese blocks for 28 cents per ounce. Compared to other grocers, customers at warehouse stores can save 11 to 34 cents per ounce, or $1.76 to $5.44 per pound. A Reddit thread showed honest reviews by shoppers and their love for the product.

A customer moves through the checkout lane with his groceries at a Costco | Getty Images | Robert Nickelsberg)
A customer at Costco (Image Source: Getty Images | Photo by Robert Nickelsberg)

Redditor u/LazyBear81 shared that they found 2-pound blocks of Tillamook on sale for $5.95 apiece. They bought 17 blocks, totaling 34 pounds, for a year's supply. The user pointed out in a comment that Tillamook Sharp Cheddar is usually between $10 and $11 and hardly falls below $9, even during sales. "Best sliced aged white cheddar in the market that’s farmer owned and uses zero hormones, zero RBSt, and zero GMO in their dairy, and you can taste the quality, and at $2.29 a half-pound pack, shut up and take my money! Oh, how I love aged white cheddar cheese, good on every sandwich and everything in between," user u/StonedTurtle420710 wrote on another Reddit thread.

(Cover Image Source: Getty Images| Photo by Tim Boyle)
Customers inside Costco (Image Source: Getty Images| Photo by Tim Boyle)

"I just paid like four dollars for these in California the other day. And I’d do it again, idgaf. It’s good stuff. Four and change, actually," u/wolf_down_the_flesh added. Consistently ranked as a top-tier cheddar and lauded for its creamy yet firm texture, Tillamook block cheese is popular when it comes to snacking. Because of its versatility, this cheddar is perfect for grilling, cheese boards, and everyday cooking. It has been reported by Fox News Digital that in Oregon, the farmer-owned cooperative Tillamook County Creamery Association uses natural milk, which does not contain any artificial growth hormones or additives to make fresh batches. 

Getty Images | Justin Sullivan
Customers inside Costco (Image Source: Getty Images | Photo by Justin Sullivan) 

Southern Living editors even crowed it a winner among rival cheeses due to the Cheddar's strong, sharp base flavor that remained consistent. While some felt the sharpness was not as pronounced as desired, most testers found the flavor refreshing. However, because of the high bulk sizes, consumers frequently find it difficult to consume the food before mold grows, convincing experts to recommend appropriate preservation techniques, including vacuum-sealing, freezing parts, or wrapping in parchment or wax paper.

More on Market Realist:

Costco announces new perk for executive members — but not everyone is happy about it

Your Costco membership comes with an extra $20 gift card right now. Here's how to get it

Costco shopper reveals a brilliant way to keep store-bought lettuce fresh for two months

RELATED TOPICS COSTCO
MORE ON MARKET REALIST
A Michigan couple’s viral membership photo struck a chord online as shoppers shared decades-old stories featuring their kids and even pets.
1 day ago
A shift to electronic payments is slowing refunds for some filers, even as the IRS grapples with staffing cuts and a heavy tax season workload.
1 day ago
The warehouse retailer is urging customers not to consume these ready-to-eat meals sold earlier this month
1 day ago
The product was distributed in several but no illness has yet been reported.
3 days ago
While most people disagreed with what the mall did, there were some who understood the reason.
3 days ago
People are seemingly having a hard time saving apart from their retirement funds.
3 days ago
“These people are working and contributing and helping to reduce the debt and deficit,” an economic expert said.
3 days ago
As per a provision in US laws, the IRS had no right to levy penalties in the pandemic years.
3 days ago
The US had sanctioned Russia heavily over its military exercise in Ukraine.
4 days ago
While gas prices have jumped, diesel prices have skyrocketed across the country, averaging at $4.78
4 days ago
Last year, Buffett stepped down as the CEO of Berkshire Hathaway.
4 days ago
Many who feel financially behind are embracing “financial nihilism,” placing bets on high-risk options instead of traditional investing.
4 days ago
It was one of the rarest instances in the show in which a contestant had won two cars in one episode
4 days ago
Housing search data flags a shift in buyer sentiment as Californians look beyond Las Vegas for cheaper housing.
4 days ago
The company is doing whatever it can to stay ahead of its competitors in the field of AI.
5 days ago
Industry leaders warn that the Iran conflict could push fertilizer costs higher and eventually drive food inflation.
5 days ago
This could lead to domestic migration of the wealthy from the state before the law takes effect
5 days ago
Karoline Leavitt says it won’t affect married women, but critics argue name-change documentation could create new barriers.
5 days ago
As regulators tighten rules and refineries shut down, the Golden State, also known as the ‘fuel island’, grapples with extremely high gas prices.
5 days ago
The answer isn't clear yet, but early signs point to his policy backfiring in a bad way.
5 days ago