ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / NEWS

'Wheel of Fortune' player wins a Mini Cooper but all fans had the same complaint: "Anyone else think..."

There was also controversy over an answer and the contestant kept yelling for judges to count it.
PUBLISHED MAR 6, 2025
'Wheel of Fortune' player with Ryan Seacret on the show (Image Source: YouTube|Wheel of Fortune)
'Wheel of Fortune' player with Ryan Seacret on the show (Image Source: YouTube|Wheel of Fortune)

Some unique characters with peculiar quirks and antics have been featured on "Wheel Of Fortune" for the decades that it has been on air. While most were fun to watch, fans weren't happy about those who went too far. One such contestant was P.J. Wilder, who was dubbed “the most annoying contestant ever" by fans on social media.

Screenshot showing Wilder alongside the host (Image source: YouTube/ The Wheel Of Fortune)
Screenshot showing Wilder alongside the host (Image source: YouTube/ The Wheel Of Fortune)

Wilder, a house husband from Hanford, California, initially stood out as a unique character for his looks. Donning a massive mustache and a mullet, the player managed to intrigue the host. As Seacrest asked about the inspiration behind the look, Wilder shared that he got it from his favorite fictional character, Hercule Poirot from Agatha Christie’s novels.

“Do you mind if I ask… apple sauce, how… can you?” Seacrest asked the player, wondering if food gets stuck in his mustache. Wilder joked that he uses two spoons to eat, one for maneuvering his mustache and the other to eat. 

Screenshot showing the contestant acting funny (Image source: YouTube/ The Wheel Of Fortune)
Screenshot showing the contestant acting funny (Image source: YouTube/ The Wheel Of Fortune)

While his jokes sparked laughter, his gameplay did not go down well. He failed to win in the first couple of rounds before finally winning $4,200 and a $8,260 trip to Antigua in the Express Round. His celebration in Spanish was the first thing that may have ticked off the viewers. The player then went on to ace a puzzle that read "OMELET STATION” in the Triple Toss-Up round. "I call them Bomblets," he commented to keep up his antics. In the final Speed Up puzzle, Wilder again aced the puzzle “SAND IN MY SWIMSUIT,” but he paused between the last words, leading to some controversy, according to TV Insider.

The host then conferred with the judges to see if the answer could be accepted as Wilder yelled, “Count it! Count it!” in the background. This made even the fellow contestants uncomfortable. Luckily for Wilder, the answer was accepted, handing him the win. This meant he got a chance to play in the Bonus Round of the show with big prizes on the line. “You cannot change the station. I don’t know what’s going to happen with him in the Bonus Round, but it’s going to be interesting," Seacrest said before breaking into a commercial as per the publication. 

For the Bonus Round, Wilder chose the category, "What are you wearing," and after filling in the standard letters, "R, S, T, L, and E," he got only one letter on the board for the three-word puzzle. 

Screenshot showing the puzzle
Screenshot showing the puzzle (Image source: YouTube/The Wheel Of Fortune)

He then went on to choose the additional letters "D, P, M, and O" as his additional letters. He lucked out with the choice of letters, as the entire puzzle was nearly filled out with the letters. Keeping up with his run, Wilder aced the puzzle guessing "ZIP-UP HOODIE". "Is this really happening, pinch me please!" Wilder said to Seacrest, continuing with his over-the-top antics.



 

In the end, Seacrest revealed that Wilder won a Mini Cooper S Signature Convertible worth $41,200, which took his total winnings to $74,860. While it was a great run for Wilder on the show, viewers watching at home did not appreciate what they saw. Taking to the show's unofficial Reddit forum, one fan complained, "Anyone else think this guy PJ is the most annoying contestant ever?"

Several others chimed in. "I don’t remember the last time I felt uncomfortable watching a contestant," @Alternative-Koala933 wrote."I literally came here to express the same sentiment. I don't think I've ever seen a contestant that irritated me so much 😆" @dataexception added

Many criticized the player for ignoring his wife after winning the car. "Came on here to see if anyone else would mention about this. Wow, he was unbearable to watch especially when he kept cutting Ryan off. Notice how his wife just stood there on the side? So awkward," @Kindly_Schedule3928 remarked

MORE ON MARKET REALIST
Host Drew Carey had to point out how loud the viewers were before the emotional victory.
5 hours ago
While the guest got a massive appraisal for her grandma's ring, she was clear on her stand.
6 hours ago
While some blamed the tough puzzle, a few were disappointed with the player, Rob Schwandt.
9 hours ago
The player was a bit too excited for the trip and so was her husband in the audience.
1 day ago
The player, Ashton Hildebrand when on to win the showcase for prizes worth over $52,000.
1 day ago
The guest, Jad managed to bring a deal back from the dead and get exactly the amount he asked for.
1 day ago
While some players played it safe, others destroyed their marriages on the show.
1 day ago
Harvey was sure tha the player, Darren didn't want to be on the show at all.
2 days ago
The unexpected collaboration aims to solve a long-standing home surveillance issue.
2 days ago
The co-founders of Y'all Sweet Tea blew away the Sharks with their incredible numbers.
3 days ago
From his lips to his bald head, Harvey has to defends all sort of jabs.
3 days ago
The woman who gifted the painting to the owners had earlier sold it to another dealer as she couldnt sleep at night.
5 days ago
When it came to naming something of Harvey they would want to touch, the players didn't hold back
5 days ago
Rick Harrison's go to expert warned him not to touch it with a "10 foot pole."
5 days ago
The massive manufacturer has been operational for more than a hundred years now.
6 days ago
While the player was overwhelmed with emotion, host, Drew Carey was left hanging for a handshake.
Oct 3, 2025
Turns out, the guest's father was the renowned artist, Demetrios Jameson.
Oct 3, 2025
While the player, Rodney Flippen took the loss on the chin, fans were left heartbroken.
Oct 2, 2025
Harvey was stunned to see that Lisa would risk her marriage to get the top answer.
Oct 2, 2025
The outbreak has been linked to four deaths, and 19 hospitalizations, according to the CDC.
Oct 2, 2025