ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / NEWS

Judge Judy's most iconic case involved two people fighting over a dog. Then, she let the pup decide.

Dogs usually don't get a say in courtrooms but not every courtroom has Judy Sheindlin as the judge.
PUBLISHED JAN 12, 2025
Screenshots showing Judy Sheindlin and the dog on "Judge Judy" (Cover image source: YouTube | Judge Judy)
Screenshots showing Judy Sheindlin and the dog on "Judge Judy" (Cover image source: YouTube | Judge Judy)

If courtroom dramas were entertaining, the rise of reality shows based in courts has gained immense popularity and turned relatable judges into celebrities. Judy Sheindlin, better known as Judge Judy, is among the most loved judges in the country today for the tact and sensitivity with which she handles complicated cases. One such case was a dispute about the ownership of a dog and the plaintiff was a man who said that the dog was his, while the defendant was a woman who said that she had purchased the canine for $50 as per Woman's World.

The dog’s name was Baby Boy and unlike other cases, Judge Judy had to take a path not well defined by the American legal system to settle the dispute. When it comes to disputes over inanimate property such as land or a house, there is a process for judges to follow before they deliver their judgment. But it's a whole different dilemma when the disputed property in question is a living, breathing animal.

Screenshot showing the plaintiff (L) and the defendant (R) on
Screenshot showing the plaintiff (L) and the defendant (R) on "Judge Judy" (Image source: YouTube | Viral Videos)

Well, Judge Judy decided to let the dog decide for itself, putting her faith in the power of love and the loyalty that canines are known for. In this case, Baby Boy did not even have to think twice before he ran over to the plaintiff, and hence the case was closed with a reunion.

The defendant could be heard saying, “He does that with everyone” but the veteran judge was having none of it. The plaintiff had tears in his eyes when Baby Boy ran to him, and that was evidence enough for Judge Judy to make her final decision. Both the dog and the plaintiff seemed extremely happy with one another and that’s all that mattered for the celebrity judge.



 

Judy Sheindlin has been in the reality TV industry for more than two decades now and the 82-year-old does not believe much has changed in that time period. According to a report in FOX, she mentioned how the main factor that drives a TV show based around a real courtroom and real cases is simply about the entertainment value of the cases. Judges have to sign off on several cases in a single day but not every one of them is intriguing enough to have a spot on daytime television.

"First of all, a court program, in order to be sustainable, has to be entertaining. Because, after all, we are in the entertainment business. So court has to be interesting, which means that the people who are delivering whatever kind of justice is being delivered each day, have to be interesting to watch,” she said.



 

Sheindlin even says that the entertainment value that viewers look for when they turn on an episode of “Judge Judy” or “Judy Justice” often comes from the distress of other people. As horrible as that may sound, it’s just the truth as per the veteran judge. "Court is a storytelling process. It's a once upon a time and the end," she added.

MORE ON MARKET REALIST
The Batman Utility Belt from the 60's turned out be a sought-after toy.
1 hour ago
Fallon got on Steve Harvey's nerves by mixing up the show with "Jeopardy!"
22 hours ago
The guest had no idea that the hood ornament was created by renowned artist Harriet Frishmuth.
1 day ago
Fans took to Reddit to discuss the player's performance and what they described as a lucky win.
1 day ago
Harrison couldn't believe his eyes when he saw one of the Holy Grails of American history.
2 days ago
This was the first time that Harrison had come across an IndyCar on sale.
2 days ago
The item turned out to be worth 10 times more than what the guest expected its value to be.
2 days ago
Cuban was against a royalty deal offered by his fellow Sharks, Lori Greiner and Robert Herjavec.
3 days ago
The collection of 11 national championship rings was from the UConn Women's Basketball dynasty.
3 days ago
Fans alleged that the show is using increasingly difficult puzzles in the Bonus Rounds.
3 days ago
The guest had endured a lot of criticism for buying the prints at even such a low price.
5 days ago
Things got intense for her as she unlocked a mega cash with just one key in her hand in the "Master Key" game.
5 days ago
A popular name has come up in every conversation about White's successor.
5 days ago
Lori Greiner wasn't happy at all as Mark Cuban and Maria Sharapova snubbed her for a deal.
6 days ago
Fans took to Reddit to discuss the issue with Seacrest not reminding the players of one crucial element.
6 days ago
When Rick Harrison's side kick bought King Booker's boots, he had to make sure it was the real deal.
7 days ago
Turns out the Hollywood star is quite the fan of former U.S. President, Ronald Reagan.
7 days ago
Harrison bagged one of Jabbar's personal items and a chance to go to a Lakers game with him
7 days ago
Recently, the Bonus Round of the show has featured many old phrases that led to heartbreaking losses.
7 days ago
Lubetzky was the first to drop out but then came back as he was impressed by the entrepreneur.
May 28, 2025