ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / NEWS

Couple Discovers Bizarre Intentions Behind Facebook Marketplace Rental Scam

The Carrolls were caught off guard when an unauthorized listing of their property emerged on Facebook Marketplace.
PUBLISHED FEB 20, 2024
Cover Image Source: A girl browses the social networking site Facebook | Getty Images | Photo by Chris Jackson
Cover Image Source: A girl browses the social networking site Facebook | Getty Images | Photo by Chris Jackson

In the quaint town of Fayetteville, New York, a seasoned couple, David and Susan Carroll, found themselves ensnared in an unprecedented rental scam, unraveling a web of deception that has left them $2,400 lighter. With a rental history dating back to 2005, the Carrolls were caught off guard when an unauthorized listing of their property emerged on Facebook Marketplace, offering the residence at a fraction of its actual rental value.

Man Scrolling Through Facebook Marketplace (representative image) | Unsplash | Photo by Thought Catalog
User scrolling Facebook Marketplace (representative image) | Unsplash | Photo by Thought Catalog

Reflecting on this baffling situation, Mr. Carroll recounted the unfortunate turn of events, emphasizing that the unsuspecting victims, lured by the fabricated Facebook listing, willingly paid the scammers the substantial sum of $2,400, per 9WSYR. This marked a stark deviation from the couple's extensive experience in property rentals, introducing a disconcerting element that challenged their confidence in the seemingly secure realm of real estate transactions. The perplexing saga took an unexpected turn when, merely a week later, another individual narrowly avoided falling prey to the same fraudulent scheme. A Facebook listing for the identical property raised red flags for the Carrolls, prompting them to delve into an investigative quest to unravel the machinations behind this duplicitous act.

Facial-recognition technology | Photo by Ian Waldie | Getty Images
Facial-recognition technology | Photo by Ian Waldie | Getty Images

In a bid to unmask the orchestrator of this nefarious plot, the Carrolls embarked on a digital pursuit, tracking down the individual responsible for the deceptive Facebook Marketplace listing. To their bewilderment, the person behind the scam was revealed to harbor a bizarre intention—to rent the Carrolls their own house. This revelation added a surreal twist to an already confounding narrative, leaving the couple grappling with the absurdity of the situation.

Adding to the ironic nature of the scam, the scammer had employed a photograph of a reputable realtor based in Florida, a figure who had previously spoken out against such fraudulent activities. In a twist of fate, the very image used by the scammer to perpetrate the deception turned out to be that of a legitimate real estate professional with a credible standing in the Jacksonville area. This discovery added a layer of complexity to the narrative, blurring the lines between reality and deception.

Facebook Marketplace scams people lossing dollars everyday | (representative image) | Pexels | Photo by Tobias Dziuba
Facebook Marketplace scams | (representative image) | Pexels | Photo by Tobias Dziuba

While the victims retain a glimmer of hope to recover their lost funds, the harsh reality of the situation was elucidated by the Onondaga County District Attorney's Office. According to Peter Hakes, the senior assistant district attorney, the process of retrieving the funds is an arduous and protracted one. Expressing a commitment to justice, Hakes emphasized the necessity of identifying and holding the perpetrators accountable, acknowledging that the chances of success diminish as time elapses and the ill-gotten funds vanish into the abyss of digital transactions.

The Onondaga County District Attorney's Office, thrust into action by this alarming case, is now diligently investigating this incident, which joins a growing list of similar scams. The complexity of such cases underscores the challenges faced by law enforcement in tracing and prosecuting individuals engaged in online fraud. As the Carrolls grapple with the aftermath of this strange experience, they have taken proactive measures to safeguard potential renters. Employing a preventive strategy, they have begun watermarking images of their properties, a visual cue intended to signal the legitimacy of their advertisements and protect prospective tenants from falling victim to deceptive schemes.

MORE ON MARKET REALIST
The guest, who found the item online, didn't think it was the real deal until he heard its value.
15 hours ago
The player Samantha secured the first big win of Ryan Seacrest's run on the show.
18 hours ago
The sisters wanted to keep their father's legacy alive, but also had their careers to focus on.
20 hours ago
The shopper noticed that the watermelon which she bought three days ago was deflated.
21 hours ago
The guest couldn't believe that her collection was worth so much money.
1 day ago
While all the Sharks were out, Mark Cuban saw the potential in "Garage Celebrations."
2 days ago
The loss was ironic as the retired teacher coulnd't get a phrase commonly used in classrooms.
2 days ago
The recalls were issued for a range of products including tires, air conditioners and power banks.
2 days ago
The guest who got the item as a gift from a neighbor had little to no idea about its significance.
2 days ago
Harrison got a good deal for the fossil although it wasn't what he had thought.
3 days ago
The player, Beth Barbee left everyone in the dust with her impressive puzzle solving skills.
3 days ago
Given her celebrity status, Harrison cut her some slack in the negotiations.
3 days ago
The deal ultimately fell apart as the seller, Scotty was looking to get $375,000.
4 days ago
The guest was blown away by the six-figure appraisal for his father's John Falter illustration.
4 days ago
Harvey just couldn't believe that the contestant could come up with an answer like that.
5 days ago
Antoinette's win was even more special because she needed a car more than anything at that point.
5 days ago
The player, Catrice Sandt, nearly blew the Bonus Round puzzle by saying too many words in the end.
6 days ago
The co-founders of Nature's Wild Berry left the Sharks in shock with their miraculous product.
6 days ago
The contestant named Whitney could barely control her emotions as she celebrated with Ryan Seacrest.
6 days ago
The player named Kathy Young missed out on the Showcase Showdown as she had to leave.
7 days ago