ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / ECONOMY & WORK

'Pawn Stars' host Chumlee pays a small fortune for guest's Pokémon card with a rare defect

The card had a manufactuting defect but that is what made it so valuable.
PUBLISHED JUL 29, 2025
Screenshot showing Chumlee and the guest on "Pawn Stars" (Cover image source: YouTube | Pawn Stars)
Screenshot showing Chumlee and the guest on "Pawn Stars" (Cover image source: YouTube | Pawn Stars)

Collectibles are a popular item on "Pawn Stars," and Pokémon cards have a lot of takers. However, that did not impress Rick Harrison enough to make him shell out a significant amount on them. But in another episode, Chumlee spent a lot of money to buy a single Pokémon card. It had not even turned out the way it was supposed to. It had a serious manufacturing defect, but surprisingly, that’s what made it so valuable. In the end, the pawn shop employee shelled out a pretty penny to acquire it.

The anime series has become massively popular over the years, with fans of all ages going crazy for the original show, games, and trading cards. Pokémon trading cards have been around for a long time, and thanks to their popularity, the rarest ones today can bring in a lot of money. One such card came to the shop, and it was called an ‘error card.’ The reason why that is the case is simple: there was an error in its manufacturing.

Pokémon cards usually have both sides printed. One side would have the picture of the Pokémon, and the other side would show its stats. On this particular card, both the contents of the front and back were printed on one side, overlapping one another. The card looked like a mess, but one could still figure out what should have been on the other side of it. Such error cards are extremely rare, which is why they’re so valuable.

Screenshot showing the Pokémon card. (Image credit: YouTube | Pawn Stars)
Screenshot showing the Pokémon card. (Image source: YouTube | Pawn Stars)

The card was of the ghost-type Pokémon Gastly, one of the beings from the original series. The guest said that he had purchased it from another collector and wanted $4,000 for it. Chumlee knew that such cards were worth a lot of money, but wanted to have an expert come in and take a look for authentication and valuation purposes.

Screenshot showing the expert checking the card out. (Image credit: YouTube | Pawn Stars)
Screenshot showing the expert checking the card out. (Image source: YouTube | Pawn Stars)

In came a man named Matt Quinn, Senior Grading Finalizer at CGC Trading Cards. “Yeah, you’ve got to be careful with some of these cards,” he said. Chumlee seemed to have a pretty good idea about trading cards, but a second opinion in such matters is always helpful. The expert took out a magnifying instrument and looked closely at the card to make sure that it wasn’t a fake. Once all the doubts were cleared, it was time to place a value on it.

The guest wanted $4,000, but Quinn revealed that it was worth $3,000. “I think that is a little bit conservative, but I respect your opinion,” the guest said. “His opinion is the one I have to live with,” Chumlee said. Once everything was verified, it was time for negotiations. The two bargained a bit and settled at $2,500. “I’m walking home with some cash, so I definitely played this card right,” the guest said after the transaction.

More on Market Realist:

'Pawn Stars' boss Rick Harrison refused to pay $500k for Pokemon cards — now it's worth $5 million

Chumlee from 'Pawn Stars' pays $3,500 for an 'ugly' guitar and Rick Harrison's reaction said it all

'Pawn Stars' boss Rick Harrison called 'cheap' by Chumlee after closing a 'Star Wars' deal

RELATED TOPICS PAWN STARS
MORE ON MARKET REALIST
The iconic "Jeopardy!" champion has been hosting the show for many years now.
8 hours ago
The host remembered the times he was bullied as a young kid after hearing the chant.
12 hours ago
The greeting caught Steve Harvey by surprise, and he took several seconds to regain his composure.
15 hours ago
The nascent nature of the company prevented the sharks from investing in it.
2 days ago
Harvey seemed quite annoyed after the guest revealed her surprise and rightfully so.
3 days ago
Both Rick and his son Corey had a lot of luaghs while talking about this item for obvious reasons.
3 days ago
She was just happe to be with Drew Carey on stage, and perhaps did not expect such a big win.
3 days ago
The segment started with a couple of people entering the stage wearing cakes over their heads.
3 days ago
The valuation he asked for was as crazy as the outfit he wore, and the sharks said no.
3 days ago
The contestant's answer had no lewd intention but Steve Harvey made sure it did.
4 days ago
Fans of the gameshow are known to be vocal about their needs and this was just an example of that.
4 days ago
The guest stood firm at what he wanted and Harrison was forced to raise his low-ball offer.
4 days ago
The contestant was confident in his abilities and he steered his team to an impressive win.
4 days ago
The sharks could not believe what they had just witnessed but it sure was entertaining.
5 days ago
The guest said that she wanted $15,000 but had to settle for just a couple grand.
5 days ago
Fans of the show were shocked she was not able to get it right after coming so close.
5 days ago
Corcoran was confident that the entrepreneur would take her deal but that was not the case.
6 days ago
The host's expressions upon seeing the answers on the board were absolutely priceless.
6 days ago
The guest was a friend of the Harrisons and he turned out to be quite the negotiator.
6 days ago
The guest had an item that was presumably made in the pre-1800s era, which made it valuable.
7 days ago