ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / NEWS

Judge Judy finds 'dumb' thieves guilty in mere 26 seconds — after they made one big mistake

The case that could've been a waste of time actually made her day with a hilarious moment.
PUBLISHED JAN 13, 2025
Screenshots showing Judge Judy laughing at the defendants (Cover image source: YouTube/Judge Judy/)
Screenshots showing Judge Judy laughing at the defendants (Cover image source: YouTube/Judge Judy/)

The iconic Judge Judy Sheindlin is undoubtedly one of the most recognizable faces on daytime television thanks to her show "Judge Judy" which has been popular among viewers for 25 seasons from 1996 to 2021. She has even set the Guinness World Record for appearing as a TV judge for the longest time. Over the years, she has seen quite a few cases that did nothing but waste the court's time. However, there was one such bogus case that she didn't waste her time on, as she delivered a verdict in just 26 seconds.

Screenshot showing Judge Judy in the courtroom (Image source: YouTube/Judge Judy)
Screenshot showing Judge Judy in the courtroom (Image source: YouTube/Judge Judy)

Defendants need to remember that they should never speak when not needed or say anything that could be incriminating in court. But the two defendants who appeared in a 2010 episode of "Judge Judy" clearly forgot that. The 26-second clip that recently went viral, showed the hearing of a case where the plaintiff accused two young men of stealing her purse from a college locker. The clip with more than 11 million views showed the two defendants and the plaintiff standing in front of the judge.

Screenshot showing the plaintiff  (Image source: YouTube/Judge Judy/aabsc)
Screenshot showing the plaintiff (Image source: YouTube/Judge Judy/aabsc)

Judge Judy begins by asking the plaintiff about the contents of her purse, which was stolen. The plaintiff explained that she lost $50, some gift cards, all her IDs which she had to replace, an earpiece, and a calculator.

Screenshot showing the defendants  (Image source: YouTube/Judge Judy/aabsc)
Screenshot showing the defendants (Image source: YouTube/Judge Judy/aabsc)

While things were going as usual, something fascinating happened. Before the plaintiff could finish, one of the defendants said, "There was no earpiece in it, Ma'am," while looking right at the judge. "I love it," the judge said while breaking into laughter.

Screenshot showing Judge Judy's reaction  (Image source: YouTube/Judge Judy/aabsc)
Screenshot showing Judge Judy's reaction (Image source: YouTube/Judge Judy/aabsc)

Once the defendants incriminated themselves, Judge Judy called them "Dumb and Dumber" referring to the famous comedic duo of Llyod (Jim Carey)  and Harry (Jeff Daniels) from the movie of the same name. The Judge then quickly wrapped the case by ruling in favor of the plaintiff and awarding her $500. "That's what I think it's worth, madam. Goodbye!" Judge Judy said signing off. 



 

While things were pretty straightforward this time, and the judge got everything right, there are cases where she failed to do so. In her 25-season run, there is only one case that was ever overturned. It happened with a case which involved a couple fighting for the custody of their 8-month-old son in a case that was filed in a Brooklyn family court with judge Judge Jeffrey Sunshine, as per the New York Post. 



 

During the taping, the couple shared that they were given a visitation order with no specific dates or times. Hence, no child support was paid by the father in the last six months. Sheindlin then got them to agree to set days and ordered the father to pay $50 a week in support until he next saw Sunshine. However, after reviewing her order, Judge Sunshine later ruled that Judge Judy had overstepped in her ruling and that it was inappropriate for custody rulings to take place in such a setting, which is why he overturned her verdict.

MORE ON MARKET REALIST
While Harrison really wanted the rare treasure, he just couldn't take a chance with such a high price tag.
11 hours ago
The issue triggered speculation on social media, with many questioning Walmart's product quality.
12 hours ago
The rising star of the show's Prime Video spinoff could take over as the full time host.
2 days ago
Rick who couldn't tell the difference between Pokemon and Charizard lost out on a deal of a life.
2 days ago
The guest later happily gave it away for free to a Folk Americana Roots Hall of Fame collection.
2 days ago
The guest had stumbled into the rare artifact online and didn't have to shell out a lot for it.
3 days ago
Jennings answered the question that was making the rounds on social media for quite some time.
3 days ago
While her letter picks gave her just one clue, Angie nailed the final puzzle in seconds.
4 days ago
While the player wasn't too bothered with the loss, fans didn't seem to let it go.
4 days ago
This wasn't the first time that a contestant made a fool of himself on the show.
5 days ago
Even the stingy star of the show, Rick Harrison couldn't resist paying top dollar for the item.
5 days ago
Kevin O'Leary's deal did offer more capital but didn't align with Strauss's goals.
6 days ago
Harvey was waiting for a long time for someone to give that answer.
7 days ago
All the guest could say was, "I am never going to be able to talk to my wife again."
Apr 17, 2025
The TikTok creator claimed that the brand is trying to gain attention, but some viewers disagree.
Apr 16, 2025
Harris made a last ditch attempt for the 'Holy Grail' item but it didn't go as he expected it to.
Apr 16, 2025
Jay Tope, who lost $75,000 earlier in the week, redeemed himself while playing with the star.
Apr 16, 2025
While the question was direct, the entrepreneurs kept beating around the bush.
Apr 15, 2025
Fans are posting videos of the game that they discovered at Costco retail stores.
Apr 15, 2025
Catherine also got some help from her mother who was sitting in the studio audience.
Apr 15, 2025