ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / NEWS

Complaint Raises Concerns About Fraud Detection System Depriving People of Benefits

Electronic Privacy Information Center has filed a complaint with the FTC against the state-deployed automated fraud detection system
PUBLISHED FEB 3, 2024
Cover Image Source: Pexels | Photo by Element5 Digital
Cover Image Source: Pexels | Photo by Element5 Digital

Scammers are increasingly targeting vulnerable consumers as well as netizens with their fraudulent schemes and the system is struggling to act in time to block their attempts. In yet another blow to the fight against fraud, the Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC) has filed a complaint with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) against the state-deployed automated fraud detection system, Thomson Reuters's "Fraud Detect." The software, used by government agencies in 42 states, including notable ones like Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Nevada, and the District of Columbia, is alleged to incorrectly identify fraud and violate federal rules, according to EPIC.

Pexels | Photo by Arturo  Añez
Pexels | Photo by Arturo Añez

EPIC's complaint argues that Fraud Detect employs an "opaque, proprietary algorithm" fueled by sensitive personal data. The software aims to alert benefits administrators about potentially fraudulent activities related to public benefits, such as unemployment insurance and the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP). It combines historical public benefits data with the personal information of an applicant to predict fraud and determine the appropriate level of assistance for recipients.

The data points used for fraud predictions include recipients' home addresses, shopping patterns, affiliated persons, social media profiles, and even credit scores, raising concerns about privacy and the potential misuse of personal information.

Image Source: ucdd.org
Image Source: ucdd.org

EPIC further contends that the adoption of Thomson Reuters's tool has resulted in millions of legitimate claimants being denied access to public benefits. The system categorizes applicants into five risk levels based on various metrics, such as high-dollar transactions, long-distance travel for shopping, and frequent balance inquiries.

The complaint highlights a specific incident in December 2020, where the California Employment Development Department engaged Pondera, the company behind Fraud Detect, to review 10 million unemployment insurance claims. Using the same algorithm, the system flagged 1.1 million claims as "suspicious," leading to the suspension of benefits for all these claimants. A probe conducted later revealed that little more than half of the flagged claims, approximately 54%, were legitimate.

Image Source: epic.org
Image Source: epic.org

EPIC's complaint extends beyond allegations of inaccurate fraud predictions. It raises questions about compliance with federal standards for responsible automated decision-making systems.

Furthermore, EPIC asserts that Thomson Reuters is in violation of Section 5 of the FTC Act due to engaging in unfair and deceptive trade practices, both directly and indirectly.

This complaint comes on the heels of the FTC's recent decision to prohibit drugstore chain Rite Aid from utilizing AI facial recognition systems, citing a lack of reasonable safeguards. The incident underscores a growing trend where regulatory bodies are scrutinizing the deployment of AI and automated systems, emphasizing the need for responsible and transparent practices in the development and use of such technologies.

As the debate over the ethical and legal implications of automated systems continues, the outcome of the FTC's investigation into Thomson Reuters's Fraud Detect may set important precedents for the use of similar technologies in public benefit programs across the United States. The EPIC complaint raises serious concerns about the accuracy, privacy implications, and compliance of the automated fraud detection system employed by numerous states. The repercussions of this investigation could potentially reshape the landscape of automated systems used in public services, emphasizing the importance of ethical considerations and adherence to regulatory standards.

MORE ON MARKET REALIST
While Jennings did not want to change anything about the show, he did miss a couple of old things.
3 hours ago
The expensive comic book was the first Marvel publication to introduce the character of Thor.
1 day ago
The guitar had been used for several iconic recordings with legendary musicians.
2 days ago
Gbenga Akinnagbe was shocked to find out that his item was an art piece from the famous Titus Kaphar.
2 days ago
While the contestant didn't mean to be suggestive Harvey just couldn't help taking it that way.
2 days ago
The TikTok creator claimed that it lacked a very important nutrient people sought from chicken.
2 days ago
While Harrison really wanted the rare treasure, he just couldn't take a chance with such a high price tag.
3 days ago
The issue triggered speculation on social media, with many questioning Walmart's product quality.
3 days ago
The rising star of the show's Prime Video spinoff could take over as the full time host.
5 days ago
Rick who couldn't tell the difference between Pokemon and Charizard lost out on a deal of a life.
5 days ago
The guest later happily gave it away for free to a Folk Americana Roots Hall of Fame collection.
5 days ago
The guest had stumbled into the rare artifact online and didn't have to shell out a lot for it.
6 days ago
Jennings answered the question that was making the rounds on social media for quite some time.
6 days ago
While her letter picks gave her just one clue, Angie nailed the final puzzle in seconds.
7 days ago
While the player wasn't too bothered with the loss, fans didn't seem to let it go.
7 days ago
This wasn't the first time that a contestant made a fool of himself on the show.
Apr 20, 2025
Even the stingy star of the show, Rick Harrison couldn't resist paying top dollar for the item.
Apr 20, 2025
Kevin O'Leary's deal did offer more capital but didn't align with Strauss's goals.
Apr 19, 2025
Harvey was waiting for a long time for someone to give that answer.
Apr 18, 2025
All the guest could say was, "I am never going to be able to talk to my wife again."
Apr 17, 2025