ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / NEWS

'Wheel of Fortune' contestant fumbles easy puzzle worth $40,000 — fans call it a 'brutal' loss

The player, Kathryn McWhorter, made it to the finale with a tiny margin after fighting hard.
PUBLISHED SEP 21, 2025
Screenshot showing Kathryn McWhorter attempting her Bonus Round puzzle (Cover image source: YouTube/Wheel Of Fortune)
Screenshot showing Kathryn McWhorter attempting her Bonus Round puzzle (Cover image source: YouTube/Wheel Of Fortune)

"Wheel of Fortune" fans are sympathetic towards contestants who try their best but lose out in the bonus round because of puzzles that many consider impossible to solve. But they're also ruthless in their criticism of players who throw away games, even if the puzzles aren't so hard. They were left disappointed after a player who fought hard to make it to the bonus round lost out on winning big over an easy puzzle. The contestant, Kathryn McWhorter, made it to the finale with the tiniest margins of just $176 and hoped to increase her winnings. However, she was stumped by a seemingly easy but strange puzzle, with the answer "Frozen Orange Juice," which cost her $40,000.

Screenshot showing the moment of loss (Image source: YouTube/Wheel Of Fortune)
Screenshot showing the moment of loss (Image source: YouTube/Wheel Of Fortune)

McWhorter got off to a rough start as her rival, Smith, took the early lead in the Toss Up rounds. However, she made a strong comeback in the Express Round where she cracked the prize puzzle to win an exotic Trafalgar tour of Costa Rica worth $9,176, according to Andy Nguyen's blog.

During the Triple Toss Up, it seemed like another contestant, Voloshyn, was set to overtake McWhorter and win. However, he made a blunder in the very last puzzle after failing to call a consonant, which eventually allowed McWhorted to win a total of $14,176 in cash.

Screenshot showing McWhorter alongside Seacrest at the wheel (Image source: YouTube/Wheel Of Fortune)
Screenshot showing McWhorter alongside Seacrest at the wheel (Image source: YouTube/Wheel Of Fortune)

Advancing to the Bonus Round, McWhorter chose the category "Food & Drink" for her final puzzle and joined the host, Ryan Seacrest, at the wheel. Before spinning the wheel, she brought along her husband of 16 years, named Marshall, to the stage for support. After picking out her Golden Envelope, she was faced with a three-word puzzle on the board. With the show's standard letters, "R, S, T, L, N, E, " filled in, she chose "M, C, D, and O" as her additional letters. With everything filled in, the puzzle read, "_ R O _ E N O R _ N _ E _ _ _ C E."

Screenshot showing the Bonus Round puzzle (Image source: YouTube/Wheel Of Fortune)
Screenshot showing the Bonus Round puzzle (Image source: YouTube/Wheel Of Fortune)

After Seacrest started the ten-second timer, it seemed like McWhorter had only one-third of the puzzle figured out. With the clock ticking, she yelled out guesses like, "Orange, ground; Orange brown," but none of them were correct. Co-host Vanna White then uncovered the answer, and Seacrest went on to add to the heartbreak by revealing that she had lost out on taking home an additional $40,000, which would have brought her total to $54,176.

Despite the big loss, McWhorter took it with a smile and gave Seacrest a big hug. However, fans weren't that positive about the loss as they felt the puzzle was solvable. "This is easy to solve," wrote one fan, @mother-is-pink, in the comments on YouTube. "Brutal," added @justinhall9231. 

Screenshot of a comment talking about the loss (Image source: YouTube/@scottleung9587)
Screenshot of a comment talking about the loss (Image source: YouTube/@scottleung9587)

However, some fans sympathized with the player too. "I got orange juice instantly, but ngl I've never heard of FROZEN orange juice, so maybe she was caught on that," explained @StormyDevRBLX.

More on Market Realist: 

'Wheel of Fortune' fans call out 'stupidest puzzle ever' as contestant misses out on $75,000

'Wheel of Fortune' host Ryan Seacrest tells contestant 'you can squeeze me' after major win

'Wheel of Fortune' fans have one big problem with host Ryan Seacrest: "Half the show is..."

RELATED TOPICS WHEEL OF FORTUNE
MORE ON MARKET REALIST
Harvey couldn't believe some of the answers that the Peele family came up with.
1 hour ago
Even host Ryan Seacrest admitted the puzzle was tricky to solve with the given letters.
1 hour ago
The bill in Oklahoma will reportedly affect thousands, including children entitled to the benefits.
19 hours ago
The guest who thought her gift would be worth $3,500, was left almost shaking in the end.
20 hours ago
The 30-second spot pays homage to the open seating policy while celebrating its new Assigned seating
22 hours ago
President Trump also spoke about the reason why he chose Kevin Warsh as the next Fed chair nominee.
1 day ago
Taxpayers in Texas, Louisiana, or Mississippi who paid self-employment tax can get their money back.
2 days ago
Trump’s overall job approval slipped to 45% in January, down from 47% in December.
2 days ago
While the host found the answers stupid, the survey thought otherwise.
3 days ago
Shopper/TikTok creator, Jimmy Wrigg found beef and ham products to be half their labelled weight
3 days ago
Referring to his previous lawsuits, the president said he would be coming after Noah for "plenty$"
3 days ago
Harvey found the answer so stupid that he couldn't give up his chance to roast
3 days ago
Harvey got hyped after he found something in common with the NFL Hall of Famers.
4 days ago
Winning $20,000 on "Family Feud" is a big deal and emotions can run high. 
4 days ago
Jeff Probst will join Drew Carey to celebrate 50 seasons of Survivor.
7 days ago
The US may lose millions in tourist spending which could in turn cost 150,000 jobs as per WTTC
7 days ago
It's safe to say that Harvey has been yelled at quite a few times at home.
Jan 30, 2026
He said it will make the 2008 financial crisis look like a 'Sunday school picnic.'
Jan 29, 2026