ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / NEWS

'Antiques Roadshow' seller gets an astounding appraisal for his $400 box of toy soldiers

The guest who got the collection at an auction was shocked to find out its true value.
PUBLISHED MAY 25, 2025
Screenshots showing the guest's reaction to the appraisal and the item next to the expert (Cover image source: YouTube | Antiques Roadshow PBS)
Screenshots showing the guest's reaction to the appraisal and the item next to the expert (Cover image source: YouTube | Antiques Roadshow PBS)

From Lego sets to action figures, things that used to be all fun and games have become part of serious business, as they're fetching massive valuations as collectibles. One such item was a box of toy soldiers that a guest brought to "Antiques Roadshow," and while he got it for $400, the expert appraised it at $20,000. The man himself picked it up on a whim at an auction, and told the expert, Noel Barrett, that he intended to keep the Heydes Buffalo Wild West collection forever.

Screenshot showing the guest, the item and the expert on the show  (Image source: YouTube/Antiques Roadshow PBS)
Screenshot showing the guest, the item and the expert on the show (Image source: YouTube/Antiques Roadshow PBS)

During an "Extraordinary Finds" special episode, Barrett recalled the time he came across a unique collection, which he referred to as his favorite item on the show in 24 years. "I guess it was the Buffalo Bill Wild West cowboy show. I bought it at an auction locally here about 21 years ago," the guest said, explaining how he got the toys. He added that he paid $400, which at the time seemed like a lot of money. "I had it in my pocket and I said, 'I like it. I'll just buy it and let the devil take the hindmost.' And then that was that," he concluded.

Screenshot showing the guest talking about the item  (Image source: YouTube/Antiques Roadshow PBS)
Screenshot showing the guest talking about the item (Image source: YouTube/Antiques Roadshow PBS)

Barrett then took over to explain the provenance of the item. "It's made by the Heyde company. Heyde was the preeminent German manufacturer, and this is something they made around 1903. What's extraordinary is the large set, what's doubly extraordinary is no one played with it. It was almost untouched by human hands," he noted. 

Screenshot showing the details of the toy collection  (Image source: YouTube/Antiques Roadshow PBS)
Screenshot showing the details of the toy collection (Image source: YouTube/Antiques Roadshow PBS)

The appraiser claimed that he had never seen such a large collection in an original box. "When you see it tied in with the little original red string and it had these little paper cushions under each piece, it was just unbelievable," Barrett added. Coming to the appraisal, the expert noted that he and his colleagues did some research and talked to a dealer who had sold a similar set, which wasn't in such good condition, for $14,000. "This set on today's market I think, at auction, could bring in the neighborhood of $15,000 to $20,000," he told the guest. 

Screenshot showing Barrett sharing the appraisal  (Image source: YouTube/Antiques Roadshow PBS)
Screenshot showing Barrett sharing the appraisal (Image source: YouTube/Antiques Roadshow PBS)

The owner of the collection was pleasantly surprised as he couldn't stop laughing. "Well when my father-in-law came in for a visit and looked at it he looked at it and said, "What did you pay for it?" when I told him he made one of those faces. So, now maybe it's going to be different," he said. In the update, the guest shared that he had never taken the collection out of his house since the appraisal, and he took pictures of it with him to conventions. "To this day it's the first thing I ever bought and it is also the best!" he said.



 

To add to the guest's delight, Barrett had an update to share as well. The expert upped his appraisal to the range of $30,000 to $40,000 and claimed it could even bring more. "Under the right circumstances, it could go to $50,000," he said in the end.

MORE ON MARKET REALIST
Many who didn't like Seacrest at first seemed to have come around through the season.
17 hours ago
The guest couldn't believe her ears when she heard that her old gift from a friend was worth $10,000.
19 hours ago
The presentation from the founders of "Bear Minimum" managed to move multiple Sharks.
20 hours ago
While the expert on the BBC show did his duty of sharing an appraisal, the guest did not budge.
22 hours ago
Fans couldn't believe how quickly the contestant solved the Bonus Round puzzle.
1 day ago
The entrepreneur was called a clever negotiator by all sharks although most of them dropped out.
1 day ago
The guest was in tears after learning that her family's prized possession was worth over $100,000.
1 day ago
The guest got incredibly lucky to find a Benny Andrews painting while looking at junk.
1 day ago
The guest was shocked to learn that someone would pay $20,000 for Queen Victoria's undergarments.
2 days ago
The guest's family heirloom turned out to be exactly as valuable as he thought.
2 days ago
The guest who assumed it was an ancient Chinese artifact said it felt like 'a stab to the heart'
2 days ago
While all the sharks burned calories, most were unwilling to burn their money.
3 days ago
In an interview with CNET's Patrick Colin, Harrison showed off his vintage tech items.
3 days ago
The item, which didn't seem too useful as a cup, turned out to be a significant piece of history.
3 days ago
The player had everyone on the edge of their seats as time was running out.
4 days ago
The member complained that the store had half-eaten boxes of food on the shelves for customers.
4 days ago
The owner of Michael Jordan's three rookie cards from 1986 to 1987, who got them for $12, was hoping to get $1,000 for the set.
4 days ago
The ring with a rare Kashmir Sapphire turned out to be worth a lot more than the guest anticipated.
4 days ago
The host once again got candid to open up about one of his greatest fears.
4 days ago
The guest's $1,500 investment went up by nearly 10 times in value.
5 days ago