ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / NEWS

'Antiques Roadshow' guest gets a whopping appraisal for vase she bought at Goodwill for just $15

The appraisal turned out to be 10 times the price that the guest had paid for it.
PUBLISHED JUN 6, 2025
The expert explaining the significance of the vase and its design (Cover image source: YouTube | Antiques Roadshow)
The expert explaining the significance of the vase and its design (Cover image source: YouTube | Antiques Roadshow)

Thrift stores aren't simply places where resellers pick up goods at low prices to flip for a profit, but these shops also have valuable artifacts hidden in them. This was true for a guest on "Antiques Roadshow," who found a century-old pottery vase at her local thrift store. Even the show's expert, David Lackey, was astonished to see that the Roseville Pottery Pauleo Vase had survived for so long without getting a scratch on it. In the end, he revealed that the guest's $15 purchase was worth over $2,000, which was more than ten times its price. 

Screenshot showing the expert, the item and the guest on the show (Image source: YouTube/Antiques Roadshow PBS)
Screenshot showing the expert, the item and the guest on the show (Image source: YouTube/Antiques Roadshow PBS)

The guest shared the incredible story of how she found the beautiful vase while browsing through a thrift store. "So I bought this at Goodwill last summer and it was kind of a whim purchase, and I love the colors. I love the style. And I've been trying to keep it from my cat for six months," she told Lackey, before adding that all she paid for it was $15.

When asked about what she found unique about the vase, the guest explained that the pattern reminded her of mermaid scales or fish scales that keep drawing her to it. Taking over from her, Lackey revealed that it wasn't any ordinary vase but a significant one. "You popped it out on the table and  went, 'know what that is.' That's Italian, 1950s. Look at the glaze. Look at the colors," he exclaimed.

Screenshot showing the guest listening to Lackey (Image source: YouTube/Antiques Roadshow PBS)
Screenshot showing the guest listening to Lackey (Image source: YouTube/Antiques Roadshow PBS)

However, he then noted that at the bottom of the vase, its design indicated that it wasn't Italian but American. "It's early 20th century. Actually, it was made in Ohio. It's made by Roseville Pottery and it's a fairly early line of Roseville Pottery," he explained. He added that it was made in about 1914, and before that, Roseville was known for making higher-quality artist pieces of smaller production wares. "They weren't doing so well financially. So right around  1910-15, they started moving into production wares, things that were more mass-produced, that could make them quicker, and cheaper, and easier. Lesser quality but higher production numbers," he shared.

Screenshot showing the expert examining the item (Image source: YouTube/Antiques Roadshow PBS)
Screenshot showing the expert examining the item (Image source: YouTube/Antiques Roadshow PBS)

Lackey noted that the vase was from a line called Pauleo, which included many different types of glazes like the vase in front of them. "This particular is kind of a crackle glaze," he said. He further noted that, despite being mass-produced, the Pauleo line was still considered to be rare. "They didn't make a lot of it. One thing I really like about it is the handles. They don't seem like much, but they're actually a key part of the aesthetics of it, the way they come down and spread out at the edge. And this glaze is very prone to scratch and for this to have ended up in Goodwill without any scratches through its entire life, which is basically over 100 years old. It's the condition is surprising," Lackey commented.

Coming to the appraisal, the expert estimated that the retail value of the vase in the market at the time would be between $1,500 and $2,000. This left the guest in shock as she couldn't believe that her $15 thrift store find was so valuable. 



 

"Wow! There's a reason why I kept it from the cat. Beautiful!" the guest exclaimed in the end.

MORE ON MARKET REALIST
Many who didn't like Seacrest at first seemed to have come around through the season.
1 day ago
The guest couldn't believe her ears when she heard that her old gift from a friend was worth $10,000.
1 day ago
The presentation from the founders of "Bear Minimum" managed to move multiple Sharks.
1 day ago
While the expert on the BBC show did his duty of sharing an appraisal, the guest did not budge.
1 day ago
Fans couldn't believe how quickly the contestant solved the Bonus Round puzzle.
2 days ago
The entrepreneur was called a clever negotiator by all sharks although most of them dropped out.
2 days ago
The guest was in tears after learning that her family's prized possession was worth over $100,000.
2 days ago
The guest got incredibly lucky to find a Benny Andrews painting while looking at junk.
2 days ago
The guest was shocked to learn that someone would pay $20,000 for Queen Victoria's undergarments.
3 days ago
The guest's family heirloom turned out to be exactly as valuable as he thought.
3 days ago
The guest who assumed it was an ancient Chinese artifact said it felt like 'a stab to the heart'
3 days ago
While all the sharks burned calories, most were unwilling to burn their money.
4 days ago
In an interview with CNET's Patrick Colin, Harrison showed off his vintage tech items.
4 days ago
The item, which didn't seem too useful as a cup, turned out to be a significant piece of history.
4 days ago
The player had everyone on the edge of their seats as time was running out.
5 days ago
The member complained that the store had half-eaten boxes of food on the shelves for customers.
5 days ago
The owner of Michael Jordan's three rookie cards from 1986 to 1987, who got them for $12, was hoping to get $1,000 for the set.
5 days ago
The ring with a rare Kashmir Sapphire turned out to be worth a lot more than the guest anticipated.
5 days ago
The host once again got candid to open up about one of his greatest fears.
5 days ago
The guest's $1,500 investment went up by nearly 10 times in value.
6 days ago