ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / NEWS

Walmart customer requests a cake with special instructions on top. What she received left her stunned.

The decorator still didn't get it when the woman returned to Walmart with her cake.
PUBLISHED DEC 23, 2024
Screenshots showing the creator and the cake that inspired her order (Image source: TikTok | @peychimack)
Screenshots showing the creator and the cake that inspired her order (Image source: TikTok | @peychimack)

While it is good to be specific about what needs to be written on a customized cake, sometimes it could backfire. Such was the case for a Chicago area-based woman Peyton Chimack (@peychimack on TikTok) who went viral after posting pictures of a cake she ordered from her local Walmart. While the birthday girl was going for a trendy cake, the cake decorator took her instructions too literally leading to a hilarious mishap.

Representative image of a birthday cake (Photo by Nick Stephenson on Unsplash)
Representative image of a birthday cake (Photo by Nick Stephenson on Unsplash)

Custom birthday cakes from Walmart recently went viral on TikTok with several users posting aesthetically pleasing images of cakes with cursive writing. An extension of the “coquette” trend, the custom trendy cakes have taken over social media this year. Thus, the 22-year-old TikToker also wanted a custom cake for her birthday. Inspired by the “thirsty” cake that went viral she chose the words "Aries Baby" to be written in small cursive writing, in the middle of the cake. 

It's safe to say that the cake decorator at Walmart did just that. Chimack told PEOPLE that when she went to pick up her cake after two days along with a friend, they collected it without checking, but later when they opened the box, they got a hilarious surprise. The decorator took Chimack's directions quite literally and wrote on the cake "Aries Baby (small, cursive, middle of the cake)" in large black lettering on the cake. 

Screenshots showing the inspiration and the actual cake (Image source: @peychimack/TikTok)
Screenshots showing the inspiration and the actual cake (Image source: @peychimack/TikTok)

"When I tell you my mouth dropped when I got in the car and opened up the cake," she wrote in the caption of her viral post. 

Viewers in the comments were cracking up adding to the fun. "LMFAO. Honestly, i love it," @envykailynn commented. "This happened when my brother was a kid and he wanted a Tom Brady jersey on his cake and they wrote happy birthday Tom Brady," another user @dwybiodv shared. 

Screenshot of a comment about the cake (Image source: @cherryblowsome/TikTok)
Screenshot of a comment about the cake (Image source: @cherryblowsome/TikTok)

An honest mistake?

Chimack told PEOPLE that when she went back to the store, the cake decorator was on lunch. However, when the butcher saw the cake, he couldn't stop laughing. When the decorator got back, Chimack said that she was confused about what she did wrong. The decorator didn't realize that Chimack had just put specific instructions and instead thought it was what she wanted to be written the cake.



 

Chimack told her not to make the cake again and simply redo the icing and write on top of it. She wrote her name and phone number on a piece of paper to get an updated cake. While they were still nearby, Chimack says she overheard the butcher shout she didn’t “want that on the cake” and “just wants ‘Aries baby’”. 

Luckily, when Chimack returned, the cake was done right and she got what she wanted. However, the 'Aries Baby' was just in simple block letters instead of the cursive font she asked for. Chimack gladly accepted the new cake as she had limited time before the celebration. She later posted a follow-up video posing with the new cake.

"It still wasn't small or in cursive but she did the best she could,"  Chimack wrote in the caption of the follow-up video. Chimack also advised fellow customers of Walmart to be as detailed as possible and clearly specify what needs to be on the cake.

Follow Peyton Chimack (@peychimack) on TikTok for more hilarious videos.

RELATED TOPICS WALMART
MORE ON MARKET REALIST
The contestant, Sarah was already overwhelmed after making it to the big stage.
41 minutes ago
The contestant, a magician, tried to steal the watch before he lost a Toyota SUV in the Bonus Round.
5 hours ago
The Coast Guard Veteran, Josh Post flubbed the final puzzle to lose out on the big prize.
1 day ago
Two pre-packaged Caesar's Salad items have been recalled over contamination concerns.
1 day ago
Harvey decided to act out the scenario which the contestant thought would be inappropriate.
4 days ago
The contestant, Ron Sheppard was inches away from solving the Bonus Round puzzle.
4 days ago
In a major breach, the systems of Mobile Commons that serves the New York State were compromised
4 days ago
Playing "The Lion's Share", Riley Shepherd won big with just two lucky picks.
4 days ago
The new legislation will allow federal workers to quickly get back to work.
5 days ago
The player, Gary, won a brand new Toyota on his 50th wedding anniversary.
6 days ago
When a bald man came up with a strange answer, Harvey roasted his entire team.
6 days ago
Walmart's dupe of the viral cup is on sale for nearly half the price of the original.
6 days ago
Harvey admitted that he had never hear someone say this about American men.
7 days ago
The analysis shows tech giants like Meta, Oracle are pivoting to bonds and debt to fuel AI ambitions
7 days ago
The contestant, April Seubert, made a grand comeback to win prizes worth over $57,000.
Nov 10, 2025
With just a one in five chances, Phillip managed to bag the top prize.
Nov 10, 2025
Several coffee chains have been feeling the pain amid rising costs, tariffs, competition and more.
Nov 10, 2025
The radical pay plan could make Musk the world's first trillionaire in the next decade.
Nov 7, 2025
The TikTok creator, Auzi a.k.a @fatpastrychef's video sparked concerns over rude store staff.
Nov 7, 2025
Joseph Evans dethroned poet, Joyelle McSweeney to become the new champion.
Nov 7, 2025