ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / NEWS

'Wheel of Fortune' fans call out the show after player lost $50,000 due to an outdated phrase

Alex Puglisi, a first responder from Connecticut, lost out due to a rarely used phrase in the Bonus Round.
PUBLISHED MAY 11, 2025
Screenshot showing the contestant's reaction and the puzzle (Cover image source: YouTube/Wheel Of Fortune)
Screenshot showing the contestant's reaction and the puzzle (Cover image source: YouTube/Wheel Of Fortune)

Fans of "Wheel of Fortune" are unforgiving when a contestant fails to solve a puzzle that does not look so difficult, but at the same time, they slam the show's producers if they feel it was impossible to solve. The show is now facing flak for using an "outdated" phrase in the Bonus Round of the show that cost a player $73,000.  Alex Puglisi was close to winning $50,000 in the final round before it all got away from her. Fans accused the show of being a rip-off, as the phrase "On The Jukebox" in the puzzle was outdated and rarely used.

Screenshot showing the contestant alongside Ryan Seacrest (Image source: YouTube/Wheel Of Fortune)
Screenshot showing the contestant alongside Ryan Seacrest (Image source: YouTube/Wheel Of Fortune)

Puglisi was off to a flying start after solving the very first toss-up puzzle to take a $1,000 lead. While the other contestants kept landing on the Bankrupt wedge, Puglisi solved another puzzle to win $2,950 more. Unfortunately, she landed on the Bankrupt wedge during the third puzzle as well and had to start from scratch. Puglisi made a great comeback by solving puzzles on the fly to take the lead and win a trip on the Alpine rail tour. She went on to solve all three puzzles of the Triple Toss Up round as well to add $10,000 to her winnings. By the end of the initial rounds, Puglisi emerged victorious with a total of $23,469. She advanced to the Bonus Round and picked the popular category, Phrase, for the final puzzle of the episode. She was joined by her parents on stage, who cheered her on as she proceeded to spin the wheel.

Screenshot showing Puglisi spinning the wheel (Image source: YouTube/Wheel Of Fortune)
Screenshot showing Puglisi spinning the wheel (Image source: YouTube/Wheel Of Fortune)

The show's host, Ryan Seacrest, picked out the Golden Card for her, which could help her win up to $100,000 or a brand new car. As the player took center stage, she got letters, “R,S,T,L,N, E,” filled in, and went on to choose “C,D,P, and O," as her additional letters to get more clues. With all the letters filled in, the bonus puzzle read, "ON     T_E      _ _ _E_O_.”

Screenshot showing the puzzle (Image source: YouTube/Wheel Of Fortune)
Screenshot showing the puzzle (Image source: YouTube/Wheel Of Fortune)

Right off the bat, it appeared that Puglisi had to guess an unusual phrase. As Seacrest set off the ten-second timer, the player looked visibly stumped. She tried to get the answer with guesses such as “On the Endzone,” “On the Ride out,” but none of them were correct. Once the time ran out, Seacrest revealed the answer was "ON THE JUKEBOX." Adding to the heartbreak, the host showed the contestant that she lost out on winning an additional $50,000 from her Golden Envelope.



 

While Puglisi was happy to walk home with over $23,000, fans took to the comments section of YouTube to express outrage. Many called the show unfair as they claimed that the phrase of the bonus puzzle was outdated. "If it was 1953 I would be disappointed in her and myself not getting it, when is the last time you heard the word Jukebox?" @streamofconsciousness5826 asked. "I've never heard of 'On The Jukebox' in my life, and I'm a sucker of 1970's and 1980's memorabilia," @lunamelody2025 mentioned.

Screenshot of a comment criticizing the puzzle (Image source: YouTube/@robertschiavo7773)
Screenshot of a comment criticizing the puzzle (Image source: YouTube/@robertschiavo7773)

Many called the puzzle a rip-off while trying to reason with it. "Ripoff puzzle. What kind of phrase is that? Whoever said that or heard of that in their lifetime, really?!?" @loveforeignaccents wrote. "That was tough!! Who would choose a j, k, or an x? If b, maybe a chance, but still tough!!" @pamelas.3023 suggested.

MORE ON MARKET REALIST
Jimmy Alexander became the first player to lose a brand-new car on season 43 of the show.
2 hours ago
The contestant, Brianne Peterson got extremely unlucky with her letter picks for the final puzzle.
4 hours ago
The guest was told that the Jasper Johns Flag Print wouldn't be valuable but it was worth thousands.
5 hours ago
It didn’t help that Alvin Rosales was playfully scolded by the host just before losing the Bonus Round.
23 hours ago
The photos featured some looks of the show's legendary former host, Alex Trebek, as well.
1 day ago
The player, Kate Stuntz, pulled off a miraculous win to take home over $68,000 and a trip to Iceland.
1 day ago
The owner couldn’t believe the value of Jane Peterson’s "The Floats" gouache painting.
1 day ago
The player, Callie DeWeese, failed to choose the right letters in the Bonus Round, leading to her loss.
2 days ago
The personal digs at the host have been relentless on the show by producers and players.
2 days ago
The guest had no idea how valuable her grandfathers Dutch tinware coffee pot was.
3 days ago
It wasn't one of Steve Harvey's jokes that cracked Bridget up so bad.
3 days ago
Fans now won't be able to stream more than five most recent episodes of the new season.
3 days ago
Despite the questionable morality of CATE App, Neal Desai managed to partner with two Sharks.
4 days ago
A supplier of Costco's Dubai Styled chocolate issued a notice regarding misinformation of allergens.
4 days ago
While some felt the puzzle was easy, many agreed that the player's letter picks let her down.
4 days ago
Harvey couldn't believe that a contestant mentioned John Madden as a response to the question.
5 days ago
The host was impressed with the contestant, John Boese's puzzle solving skills.
5 days ago
Despite making a decent offer, Harrison could not make a deal for the rare Mormon Bank Dollar.
5 days ago
The player, Lisa Santangelo, was dumbfounded by a puzzle that was allegedly reused by the show.
6 days ago
The player, Brittany Brock was visibly shaken after the big $40,000 win in the Bonus Round.
6 days ago