ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / NEWS

'Judge Judy' plaintiff’s awful joke at courtoom still remains the weirdest moment in show history

Given the show's long run, Judge Judy Sheindlin has witnessed some awkward and cringeworthy moments.
PUBLISHED DEC 26, 2024
Screenshots showing Judge Judy and the plaintiff (Image source: YouTube/Judge Judy/Ben Gough)
Screenshots showing Judge Judy and the plaintiff (Image source: YouTube/Judge Judy/Ben Gough)

In its prestigious 25-year run, the show "Judge Judy" has produced some of the most iconic moments in television history. However, the star Judge Judy Sheindlin has also witnessed some awkward and cringeworthy moments. One such moment where a terrible joke landed face first, was picked as the 'cringiest' of all time by the fans of the show. 

Screenshot showing the defandants and the plaintiff (Image source: YouTube/Judge Judy/Ben Gough)
Screenshot showing the defandants and the plaintiff (Image source: YouTube/Judge Judy/Ben Gough)

An Embarrassing Turn of Events

Hearing a case of a dispute between a landlord and a tenant couple, Judge Judy asked the plaintiff a simple question, "The defendants were tenants, and is that in your home, apartment, or condo?" All the plaintiff had to answer with just one word and the case would have proceeded fine. However, the man had different plans which seemed funny, at least to him.

After taking a brief pause, the plaintiff very convincingly replied, "It was in the basement of my trailer," which instantly didn't make sense to anyone in the silent courtroom. "No, I'm just kidding it was in the basement of my home," the man added.

Screenshot showing the jokester (Image source: YouTube/Judge Judy/Ben Gough)
Screenshot showing the man who tried to crack a joke (Image source: YouTube/Judge Judy/Ben Gough)

While he thought he made a funny joke, the entire courtroom went quiet instead of bursting into laughter. Even Judge Judy wasn't having any of the funny stuff. "We got off on the wrong foot Mr. Russell, I'm going to assume you wanted to get off on the right foot with me so we're going to start again," she told the plaintiff right away. 

Screenshot showing Judge Judy's reaction (Image source: YouTube/Judge Judy/Ben Gough)
Screenshot showing Judge Judy's reaction (Image source: YouTube/Judge Judy/Ben Gough)

Nevertheless, it's moments like these that made the show ever-so-popular. Even though the original show ended in 2021, fans still get to watch Judy Sheindlin hear cases on her new show. 



 

A New Chapter For Judge Judy

Sheindlin is still going strong on television after signing a new record-breaking deal with Amazon. After ending her 25-year stint with CBS, she made a return to television with the new show 'Judy Justice'.  



 

Speaking on her future and retirement plans, Sheindling told The Hollywood Reporter, that there are none. "I know what I like to do. Why, at my stage in life, would I try to find something else when I already know what I like? And this isn’t a 9-to-5 job. I’ve still got the time to see the children I love, the grandchildren who are growing up very fast, and the cute mate who I still get a kick out of," she said. 

Her relentless work ethic and strong persona allowed Sheindlin to amass a staggering net worth of $560 million according to Forbes. During her time with "Judge Judy," she reportedly took a $47 million salary per year before the rights of the episodes were bought by CBS for a reported $100 million. 



 

While Sheindling hasn't disclosed her current salary for "Judy Justice", the New York Times analysts estimate that she has received about $25 million for taping the first 120 episodes of the show, which airs on Amazon's Freevee. Apart from this, she has also created two other shows for the platform, details of which are also undisclosed.

MORE ON MARKET REALIST
The host couldn't help but sarcastically play along with the contestant.
14 minutes ago
When the Maheshwari family insisted, and the audience cheered, the veteran host pulled off some moves
2 hours ago
U.S. Trade Representative launched Section 301 probes into unfair trade practices of 60 countries
2 days ago
The Customs and Border Protection said the four-part refund system will be operational in a few weeks
3 days ago
Jeopardy! threw indirect shade at the actor for saying no one cares about Ballet and Opera .
3 days ago
Harvey, in his wildest imagination, couldn't believe the answer was popular.
4 days ago
The host couldn't believe his eyes when the answer showed up on the board.
4 days ago
David Malpass told Fox Business that U.S. energy independence will be crucial for growth measures
4 days ago
Sen. Rick Scott has proposed 'American Dream Accounts' that would help people save for a home.
4 days ago
The nonpartisan fiscal watchdog CFRB has warned that the U.S. may be heading blindly into the next crisis.
5 days ago
Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei explains if AI models can actually go rogue and rebel against humans.
5 days ago
By the end of the game, Harvey was left wondering what he had just heard.
5 days ago
Senator Cory Booker is set to introduce the new tax with the aim to curb the cost-of-living crisis
5 days ago
Illinois is looking to setup Newborn Equity Support Transfer program to help mothers with childcare
5 days ago
Harvey was disappointed with the players who couldn't come up with the most obvious answers.
6 days ago
Some of the answers were too bizarre even for the seasoned host, Steve Harvey.
6 days ago
While the host fumbled the card, it had just enough for Brenda to win a brand new car
Mar 7, 2026
The nonpartisan fiscal watchdog revised its estimates to add $2 trillion to its earlier projection.
Mar 7, 2026
Chevron president Andy Walz urged the state's regulators to review their climate policy.
Mar 7, 2026