ECONOMY & WORK
MONEY 101
NEWS
PERSONAL FINANCE
NET WORTH
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use DMCA Opt-out of personalized ads
© Copyright 2023 Market Realist. Market Realist is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
MARKETREALIST.COM / ECONOMY & WORK

'Pawn Stars' boss Rick Harrison pays more than what guest wanted for OJ Simpson signed helmet

This wasn't the first time that an appraisal by an expert worked in favor of the seller.
PUBLISHED JUN 28, 2025
Rick Harrison looking at the signatures on the helmet (Cover image source: YouTube | Pawn Stars)
Rick Harrison looking at the signatures on the helmet (Cover image source: YouTube | Pawn Stars)

O.J. Simpson is one of the most controversial figures in recent American history, who went from being a celebrated sportsman to being accused of murder. On "Pawn Stars," a vehicle used by Simpson in an infamous car chase to evade arrest has already turned up before. During another episode of the show, a helmet signed by the football legend who fell from grace caught Rick Harrison's attention.

As opposed to the norm on “Pawn Stars,” it received a higher valuation than what the guest had expected. It was a Heisman helmet that had been signed by 28 Heisman Trophy winners. One of the biggest names on that helmet was that of O.J. Simpson. Rick Harrison seemed interested in the item, but there was just one slight problem.

The guest had a certificate of authenticity, but it was issued by a company that had gone out of business. Therefore, the 60-year-old decided to call in an expert to confirm that the signatures were genuine and to ascertain how much the helmet was worth. The guest had initially asked for $800 for the item, which had seemed like a reasonable price to the pawn shop owner. However, he had no idea that he was about to shell out more money.

Screenshot showing O.J. Simpson's signature on the helmet. (Image credit: YouTube | Pawn Stars)
Screenshot showing O.J. Simpson's signature on the helmet. (Image credit: YouTube | Pawn Stars)

The expert confirmed that the helmet’s signatures were indeed authentic and said that it would be worth $2,500. The guest certainly wasn’t expecting this and increased his asking price to $1,800. After some negotiation, the final price that was decided upon was $1,450. It was a lot less than what the helmet was valued at, but a lot higher than what the guest had asked for in the first place.



 

Out of all the signatures on the helmet, Simpson’s was perhaps the most popular. After having a stellar career and retiring from football, the former Buffalo Bills player was embroiled in a widely covered murder case. It was alleged that he had killed his former wife, Nicole Brown, and her friend, Ron Goldman, in 1994. While the former football player was cleared of all charges, people still have a hard time believing that he was innocent.

One of the biggest reasons for that was the infamous car chase. Simpson was in a white Ford Bronco driven by his friend Al Cowlings, which was chased by the police. The whole thing was televised on televisions all across the country and became a topic of discussion everywhere. The chase happened after the football player had decided against turning himself in for questioning regarding his wife’s murder.



 

Simpson was eventually cleared of all charges due to a lack of solid evidence against him. However, he was arrested in 2007 and charged with armed robbery and kidnapping. He was sentenced to 33 years' imprisonment with a minimum of nine years without parole. The former footballer finally got out of prison on parole in 2017.

MORE ON MARKET REALIST
Barbara Corcoran made the exact same offer, and she wasn't happy about being rejected.
13 hours ago
The guest believed that it was worth a modest amount of money, but that was clearly not the case.
14 hours ago
With James Holzhauer in the lead, Amy Schneider and Andrew He decided to joke around.
15 hours ago
Barbara Corcoran told the founders that she had never seen Greiner so passionate.
17 hours ago
The guest said that it was left to her by her grandmother who passed at the age of 102.
1 day ago
The host was quick to latch on to his way of speaking and made a mockery of it on TV.
1 day ago
The contestant was clearly just happy to win the chance of being on the same stage as Drew Carey.
1 day ago
The player, Thomas Russo, nearly put all of his strength into spinning the wheel.
1 day ago
Things took a turn for the better with the shark as far as the entrepreneurs were concerned.
2 days ago
The expert pointed out the intricate details on the item and said it was a personal item of the royals.
2 days ago
The expert said that if the signature was on a letterhead when Garfield was President, it would be worth more.
2 days ago
Had the contestants not gotten their gamble right, they would have lost everything they'd earned.
3 days ago
The revelation came thanks to a fan who asked the question during a "Jeopardy!" taping.
3 days ago
The entrepreneurs' decision came as a big shock to the sharks, and they did not hide it.
3 days ago
Tina double-guessed her third answer, "Does April have 31 days?" Harvey gave her the stink eye.
3 days ago
All the theatrics didn't work when sharks started scrutinizing profit margins.
3 days ago
"Can I stop at any time?" the player nervously inquired. "You can stop any time you want, yes," Carey assured.
3 days ago
Guests on the show would run with it if they ever got that kind of money on Pawn Stars.
4 days ago
The guest even said to keep the kids in the dark about how valuable these items were.
4 days ago
The company had fantastic sales but a crushing debt with a high interest rate that the sharks hated.
4 days ago