Forward valuation

In this article, we’ll look at Cleveland-Cliffs’ (CLF) valuation and compare it to those of its US steel peers. We’ll also look at its forward EV-to-EBITDA (enterprise value-to-EBITDA) and PE multiples.

What Would Lead to a Rerating of CLF’s Multiple?

Cleveland-Cliffs’ valuation

Among US steel stocks, U.S. Steel Corporation (X) and ArcelorMittal (MT) have the lowest forward EV-to-EBITDA multiples of 3.6x and 4.4x, respectively. Cleveland-Cliffs, on the other hand, is trading at the highest multiple of 6.3x. Steel Dynamics (STLD) and Nucor (NUE) follow with multiples of 6.0x and 6.1x, respectively.

Cliffs’ multiple has seen an expansion of 2% since it released its second-quarter results. Its stock price has risen 17% since then. Its current forward EV-to-EBITDA multiple still implies a discount of 20% to its trailing-five-year multiple. On a forward PE basis, CLF is trading at a multiple of 6.5x, implying a discount of 40%.

Fundamentals and value

As we highlighted in Is There a Disconnect between CLF’s Valuation and Fundamentals? Cliffs’ valuation needed to rise to reflect its improved fundamentals. While some of this improvement has already been priced in by the market, there could be room for more upside.

Cliffs’ earnings potential and margin accretion in the form of its existing US iron ore business and its HBI (hot briquetted iron) plant are looking the best they have looked in several years. Still, its valuation is far behind its historical multiples. There could be some catching up to do for its price and valuation so that these improvements are fully priced in.

The apparent disconnect may be due to investors being concerned about the future direction of steel prices. While some of these concerns may be valid, the market needs to give the company a bit more credit. Stable to slightly falling steel prices along with Cliffs’ attractive business prospects—including its HBI plant, DR-grade (direct reduced) facility, unique positioning, steady demand, long-term contracts, strong execution, and impressive balance sheet—are likely to have positioned the company to see significant returns going forward.

Read Revisiting the Case: How Does Cleveland-Cliffs Look Now? for an in-depth analysis of CLF’s fundamentals and valuation.

Latest articles

21 May

Trump’s Huawei Ban Pulls Down US Chip Stocks

WRITTEN BY Scarlett Ness

Last week, Donald Trump blacklisted Chinese telecom giant Huawei Technologies amid rising US-China trade tensions.

21 May

Snap Is Making Up for Last Year


This year has been a great one for Snapchat parent Snap (SNAP), and its stock has nearly doubled.

Coca-Cola (KO) will offer a limited edition of its of New Coke cans beginning May 23 as part of its partnership with Netflix’s (NFLX) show Stranger Things.

21 May

Why Clorox Stock Is Underperforming Peers

WRITTEN BY Adrian Stevens

Clorox stock (CLX) is down about 8% since the company posted its third quarter of fiscal 2019 earnings on May 1.

21 May

What JD Is Set to Get from Its Xinning Deal

WRITTEN BY Rachel Gunter (JD) recently invested ~$55 million in purchase a ~10% stake in Jiangsu Xinning Modern Logistics, a Chinese logistics company focusing on the consumer electronics supply chain.

Today, the US stock market was on a path of recovery after starting the week on a bearish note yesterday.